Unites States v. Guinet
Syllabus & Case Posture
The Unites States versus Guinet, et al.
THIS was an indictment against Etienne Guinet and John Baptist Le Maitre, for a misdemeanor in sitting out and arming Les Jumeaux (The Twins) in the port of Philadelphia, to be employed in the service of the Republic of France, against Great Britain, both powers being at peace with the United States. The act on which the indictment was founded, contained the following sections :
Sec. 3. And be it further enacted and declared, That if any person shall, within any of the ports, harbours, bays, rivers, or other Waters of the United States, sit out and arm, or attempt to sit out and arm, or procure to be sitted out and armed, or shall knowingly be concerned in the furnishing, sitting out or arming of any ship or vessel, with intent that such ship or vessel shall be employed in the service of any Foreign Prince or State, to cruise or commit hostilities upon the subjects, citizens or property of another Foreign Prince or State, with whom the United States are at peace, or shall issue or deliver a commission within the territory or jurisdiction of the United States, for any ship or vessel, to the intent that she may be employed as aforesaid, every such person, so offending, shall, upon conviction, be adjudged guilty of a high misdemeanor, and shall be fined and imprisoned, at the discretion of the Court in which the conviction shall be had, so as the fine to be imposed shall in no case be more than five thousand dollars, and the term of imprisonment shall not exceed three years ; and every such ship or vessel, with her tackle, apparel, and furniture, together with all materials, aims, ammunitions, and stores, which may have been procured for the building and equipment thereof, shall be forfeited, one half to the use of any person who shall give information of the offence, and the other half to the use of the United States.
Sec. 4. And be it further enacted and declared, That if any person shall, within the territory or jurisdiction of the United States, encrease or augment, or procure to be encreased or augmented, or shall be knowingly concerned in encreasing or augmenting the force of any ship of war, cruiser, or other armed vessel, which, at the time of her arrival within the United States, was a ship of war, cruiser or armed vessel in the service of a Foreign Prince or State, or belonging to the subjects or citizens of such Prince or State, the same being at war with another Foreign Prince or State with whom the United States are at peace by adding to the number or size of guns of such vessel prepared for use, or by the addition thereto of any equipment solely applicable to war, every such person so offending shall, upon conviction, be adjudged guilty of a misdemeanor, and shall be fined and imprisoned at the discretion of the Court, in which the conviction shall be had, so as that such fine shall not exceed one thousand dollars, nor the term of imprisonment be more than one year.
The indictment was brought upon the 3d section. Guinet only was apprehended ; and, being arraigned, he pleaded not guilty.
<The material fafts that appeared in evidence, upon trial, were thefe : Les Jumeaux entered at the port of Philadelphia, in the month of , laden with fugar and coffee, from Port-au-Prince; and on her arrival she mounted four guns and two swivels. The vessel, it seemed, had originally been a British cutter, employed in the trade to the coast of Guinea ; and had ten port-holes on each side, though only four were actually open, at the time of her arrival, to accommodate the four guns, then mounted. Soon after, a Frenchman applied to a ship-carpenter to repair the vessel, which was in a very rotten state ; and, after some difficulty, a bargain for that purpose was struck ; but the carpenter declared he would only open the number of ports (twenty) which were pierced when she came into port ; and in all other respects fit her for a merchant-ship. At thtime of repairing her, she was owned in shares by Le Maitre, the original owner, and seven other Frenchmen. The twenty ports being opened, and the other repairs of the vessel proceeding rapidly, the Government instituted an enquiry into the subject, in order to ascertain the nature and design of her equipments. On examination, the matter Warden found the vessel in great forwardness, her twenty ports open, her upper deck changed, &c. and four iron guns on carriages, with two swivels, were lying on the adjoining wharf. He, therefore, desired the carpenter to desist from working any further on the vessel, and made a report on the subject, to the Secretary at War ; who directed, that all the recent equipments of a warlike nature should be dismantled, and the vessel restored to the state in which she was when she arrived. The matter Warden, accordingly, caused the port holes to be shut up, and even refused to allow any ringbolts to be fixed in the vessel. A few days before she left the port a witness said he saw four guns in hehatch-way ; the carpenter who repaired her said she carried with her from the wharf, the four guns and two swivels that she had brought in ; and, according to the Custom-House Entry, she sailed from the city in ballast, having nothing in her hold but provisions, water-casks, and wood for the ship’s use. It had been said, at one time, that she was to carry flour; at another time that she was to carry passengers ; and Guinet had told the ship carpenter that she would be advertised on freight. She failed in the middle of the day, and some of the workmen went down in her as far as League-Island.
Opinion of the Court — Jitftice:
Primary OpinionJitftice:
—This is an indictment against John Etienne Guinet, for being, knowingly, concerned in furnishing, fitting out, and arming Les Jumeaux, in the port and river Delaware, with intent that the should be employed in the service of the French Republic, to cruise, or commit hostilities, upon the subjects of Great Britain, with whom the United States are at peace : And it is the province of the Jury to enquire, whether the proof exhibited on the trial, has fully maintained the charge contained in the indictment.
Much has been said upon the construction of the 3d. and 4th sections of the act of Congress ; but the Court is clearly of opinion, that the 3d section was meant to include all cases of vessels, 1 armed within our ports by one of the belligerent powers, to act as cruisers against another belligerent power in peace with the United States. Converting a ship from her original destination, with intent to commit hostilities ; or in other words, converting a merchant ship into a vessel of war, must be deemed act original outfit; for the act would, otherwise, become nugatory and inoperative. It is the conversion from the peaceable use, to the warlike purpose,. that constitutes the offence.
The vessel in question arrived in this port, with a cargo of coffee and sugar, from the West-Indies ; and so appears to have been employed by her owner with a view to merchandise, and not with a view to war. The enquiry, therefore, is limitted to this consideration, whether, after her arrival, she was fitted out, in order to cruise against any foreign nation, being at peace with the United Slates. It is true, she left the wharf with only four guns, the number that fire had brought into the port; but it is equally true, that, when she had dropped to some distance below, she took on board three or four guns more, a number of muskets, water-casks &c. ; and, it is manifest, that other guns, ready to be sent to her by the Pilot-boat. These circumstances clearly prove a conversion from the original. commercial design of the vessel, to a design of cruising against the enemies of France ; and, of course, against a nation, at peace with the United States, since the United States are at peace with all the world. Nor can it be reasonably contended, that the articles thus put on board the vessel were article's of merchandise ; for, if that had been the case, they would have been mentioned in her manifest, on clearing out of the port, whereas it is expressly stated, that she sailed in ballast. If they were not to be used for merchandise, the inference is inevitable, that they were to be used for war. No man would proclaim on the house top, that he intended to fit out a privateer : the intention must be collected from all the circumstances of the transaction which the Jury will investigate, and on which they must decide. . But if they are of opinion, that it was intended to convert this vessel from a merchant ship into a cruiser, every man who was knowingly concerned in doing so, is guilty in the contemplation of the law.
It will only, then, be necessary to ascertain, how far the defendant was knowingly, concerned ; for, though he were concerned,, if he did not ad with a knowledge of the real object, he would be innocent. It has been alledged in his defence, that he was merely an interpreter; and if, in fact, he had appeared in that character alone, we should not have thought it a sufficient ground for conviction. But the Jury will collect from the other parts of the transaction, whether this is not used as a mask to cover his efficient agency in the equipment of the vessel. He carried orders from the owner to the ship carpenter; he told the Pilot-boy at what time the guns should be taken on board his boat, to be carried to the ship ; the account found in his possession states charges for supplies of cannon, ball, muskets, and commissions for services ; and the whole is conducted in a secret and myterious manner, under the shade of night. Would he have acted this part as a mere interpreter ? If it had been fair mercantile business, involving nothing repugnant to our laws, would it have been so much a work of darkness ? This alone casts a gloom over the transaction, that will impress every just and ingenuous mind with an idea of fraud and delinquency.
If the defendant has been concerned in the offence, there is no doubt that it is effected as far as it was in his power to complete it. The illegal outfit of the vessel was accomplished ; and that an additional number of cannon was not sent to augment her force, was nor owing to his respect to the laws, but to the vigilance of the public police.
Upon the whole, the Jury will consider the indictment ; and give such a verdict as shall comport with evidence and law.
Verdict—Guilty.