SCOTUS-Cases.net

The Frances & Eliza

21 U.S. 398 1823-03-05 2,352 Words
Full Case Caption
The Frances and Eliza : Coates, Claimant
Official & Parallel Citations
8 Wheat. 398 · 21 U.S. 398 · 5 L. Ed. 645
Court & Volume
Supreme Court of the United States · 21 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

*The Frances and Eliza : Coates, Claimant.

Na/oigaiion laws. — Continuity of voyage.

If a British ship come from a foreign port (not British) to a port of tin» United States, the continuity of the voyage is not broken, and the vessel is not liable to xorfeiture, under the act of April 13th, 1818, c. 65, by touching at an intermediate British closed port, from necessity, and in order to procure provisions, without trading there.

Appeal from the District Court of Louisiana. This was an allegation of forfeiture, against the British ship Frances and Eliza, in the court below, for a breach of the act of congress, of the 18th of April 1818, c. 65, the first section of which is in these words :

“ That from and after the 30th day of September next, the ports of the United States shall be and remain closed against every vessel, owned, wholly or in part, by a subject or subjects of his Britannic Majesty, coming or arriving from any port or place in a colony or territory of his Britannic Majesty, that is or shall be, by the ordinary laws of navigation and trade, closed against vessels owned by citizens of the United States; and such vessel, that, in the course of the voyage, shall have touched at, or cleared out from, any port or place, in a colony or territory of Great Britain, which shall or may be, by the ordinary laws of navigation and trade aforesaid, open to vessels owned by citizens of tbe *United States, shall, nevertheless, be deemed to have come from the port or place in the colony or territory of Great Britain, closed, as aforesaid, against vessels owned by citizens of the United States, from which such vessel cleared out and sailed, before touching at and clearing out from an intermediate and open port or place as aforesaid ; and every such vessel, so excluded from the ports of the United States, that shall enter, or attempt to enter the same, in violation of this act, shall, with her tackle, apparel and furniture, together with the cargo on board such vessel, be forfeited to the United States.”

The libel set forth, in the words of the act, that the Frances and Eliza was owned, wholly or in part, by subjects of his Britannic Majesty, and had come from the port of Falmouth, in the Island of Jamaica, a colony of his Britannic Majesty, which port was closed against citizens of the United States, and that she attempted to enter the port of New Orleans, in the United States, contrary to the provisions of the act before recited. To this libel, William Coates, master of the vessel, put in an answer, denying the allegations in the libel, and claiming her as the property of Messrs. Herring & Richardson, of London. The material facts appearing on record, are these:

Opinion of the Court — Duvall, Justice,

Primary Opinion

Duvall, Justice,

delivered the opinion of the court, and after stating the facts, proceeded as follows : — In the argument of this cause, it was contended by the attorney-general, that touching at Falmouth, with the intention to get freight there, and coming from that port to a port in the United States, brought the Frances and Eliza within the operation of the navigation act; it being the policy of the law to prevent all communication between vessels of the United States and British ports, which were closed against them. On behalf of the owners, it was contended, that if the Frances and Eliza was bound to Falmouth, it was a mere alternative destination, depending on her being able to get freight there ; and that as she in fact embraced the other branch of the alternative, and went to New Orleans, this must be considered as her original destination.

^ tbe destination of the Frances and Eliza *from Margaritta to New Orleans, was real, not colorable; and if the touching at Fal-mouth was for the purpose of procuring provisions, of which the ship’s crew was really in want, there was not a violation of the navigation act. The evidence in the cause seems to justify the conclusion, that her real destination was to New Orleans. The order of Mr. Gold, agent of the owners, to the master, to take command of the.vessel and proceed to New Orleans, and there to endeavor to procure a freight to England or the continent ; the letter of recommendation from John Guya, merchant, to Messrs. R. D. Shepherd & Co., requesting their aid to the master to accomplish that purpose, taken in connection with the circumstance of Glover’s taking his passage in the vessel, with the leave of the agent, from Margaritta to New Orleans, establish the fact in a satisfactory manner. It appears to have been understood, by all who had any concern with the vessel, that her destination was to New Orleans.

The Frances and Eliza did not enter the port of Falmouth, but stood off and on, four or five miles from the harbor, for a few days, during which time the master went on shore to get provisions, of which he was in want. Whether he endeavored to procure freight there, is a fact not ascertained by the testimony. It is certain, that be did not obtain it, because it is admitted, that the vessel sailed in ballast to New Orleans. His real object in going on shore at Falmouth, appears to have been to procure provisions, of which the ship’s crew were much in want. And there is no ’“evidence of any act done by him, which can be construed into a breach of the act concerning navigation. The policy of that act, without doubt, was to counteract the British colonial system of navigation; to prevent British vessels from bringing British goods from the islands, in exclusion of vessels of the United States, and to place the vessels of the United States on a footing of reciprocity with British vessels. The system of equality was what was aimed at. The landing a passenger there, who casually got employment, and for that reason.chose to remain on the island; and the taking in two passengers there, on of which was a boy and a relative, and the other taken, passage free, to New Orleans, are not deemed to be acts in contravention of the true construction of the navigation act.

The log-book was supposed to furnish some suspicious appearances, but, on examination, was found to contain no material fact which could govern in the decision. It is the unanimous opinion of the court, that the sentence of the district court ought to be reversed, and that the property be restored to the claimant.

Decree reversed.

Cited By Later Decisions (1)

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).