SCOTUS-Cases.net

Chicago, Milwaukee & St. Paul Railway Co. v. Polt

232 U.S. 165 1914-01-26 No. 161 875 Words
Full Case Caption
CHICAGO, MILWAUKEE & ST. PAUL RAILWAY COMPANY v. POLT
Official & Parallel Citations
232 U.S. 165 · 58 L. Ed. 554 · 34 S. Ct. 301
Court & Volume
Supreme Court of the United States · 232 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

CHICAGO, MILWAUKEE & ST. PAUL RAILWAY COMPANY v. POLT.

ERROR TO THE . SUPREME COURT OP THE STATE OP SOUTH DAKOTA.

No. 161.

Argued January 16, 1914.

Decided January 26, 1914.

While the States have a large latitude in the policy they will pursue in regard to enforcing prompt settlement of claims against railroad companies, the rudiments of fair play to the companies as required by the Fourteenth Amendment must be recognized.

Opinion of the Court — Me. Justice Holmes

Primary Opinion

Me. Justice Holmes

delivered the opinion of the court.

This was a suit against the plaintiff in error for loss of property destroyed by fire communicated from its locomotive engine. A statute of South Dakota, after making -the Railroad Company absolutely responsible in such cases, goes on to make it liable for double the amount of damage actually sustained unless it pays the full amount .within sixty days from notice. If, within sixty days, it shall “offer in writing to pay a fixed sum, being the full amount of the damages sustained and the owner shall refuse to accept the same, then in any action thereafter brought for such damages when such owner recovers a less sum as-damages than the amount so offered, then such owner shall recover only his damages, and the railway company shall recover its costs.” South Dakota Laws, 1907, c. 215. The plaintiff got a verdict for $780. The Railroad had offered $500; less, that is, than the amount of the verdict, while the plaintiff on the other hand demanded more. In his demand, his declaration and his testimony he set the damage at $838.20. A judgment for double damages was affirmed by the Supreme Court of the State. 26 So. Dak. 378.

The defendant in error presented no argument, probably becausedie realized that under the recent decisions of this court the judgment could not be sustained. No doubt the States have a large latitude in the policy that they will pursue and enforce, but the rudiments of fair play required by the Fourteenth Amendment are wanting when a defendant is required to guess rightly what a jury will find, or pay double if that body sees fit to add one cent to the amount that was tendered, although the tender was obviously futile because of an excessive demand. The case is covered by St. Louis, Iron Mountain & Southern Ry. Co. v. Wynne, 224 U. S. 354. It is not like those in which a moderate penalty is imposed for failure to satisfy a demand found to be just. Yazoo & Mississippi Valley R. R. Co. v. Jackson Vinegar Co., 226 U. S. 217.

Judgment reversed.

Precedents Cited (6)

Cited By Later Decisions (14)

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).