SCOTUS-Cases.net

Overton v. Oklahoma

235 U.S. 31 1914-11-09 No. 40 410 Words
Full Case Caption
OVERTON v. STATE OF OKLAHOMA
Official & Parallel Citations
235 U.S. 31 · 59 L. Ed. 112 · 35 S. Ct. 14
Court & Volume
Supreme Court of the United States · 235 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

OVERTON v. STATE OF OKLAHOMA.

ERROR TO THE SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF OKLAHOMA.

No. 40.

Submitted October 19, 1914.

Decided November 9, 1914.

The court having instructed the jury that if the shipment of liquor within the State was to complete an interstate shipment the local prohibition statute did not apply, the contention that § 4180, Snyder’s Compiled Laws of Oklahoma,, is repugnant to the commerce clause of the Federal Constitution, held too frivolous to support the jurisdiction of this court to review the judgment of the state court on writ of error.

Opinion of the Court — Me. Chief Justice White.

Primary Opinion

Memorandum opinion by direction of the court, by

Me. Chief Justice White.

The verdict and sentence were on an indictment for illegally moving liquor (§ 4180, Snyder’s Compiled Laws of Oklahoma, 1909). The defense was that the movement was to complete an interstate shipment from Missouri. The court instructed that the statute did not apply to such a shipment and hence if the movement was as asserted, there must be an acquittal. Under this situation' the contention here made that the statute was repugnant to the commerce clause is too frivolous to support jurisdiction. And this is also true of the contention that there is jurisdiction because the facts establish that the conclusion of guilt could only have been reached by plainly disregarding the proof as to the' character of the shipment, thus in fact applying the statute to interstate commerce, since the record affords no justification for the assumption upon which the proposition rests.

Dismissed for want of jurisdiction.

Kansas City Southern Ry. Co. v. Albers Commission Co., 223 U. S. 573, 591; Creswill v. Knights of Pythias, 225 U. S. 246, 261; Southern Pacific Co. v. Schuyler, 227 U. S. 601, 611; Portland Ry. Co. v. Oregon R. R. Com'n, 229 U. S. 397, 411-412; Miedreich v. Lauenstein, 232 U. S. 236, 243-244; Missouri, Kans. & Tex. Ry. v. West, 232 U. S. 682, 691-692.

Precedents Cited (6)

Cited By Later Decisions (2)

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).