Armstrong v. Lear
Syllabus & Case Posture
[Lex Loci. Probate or Testamentary Paper.']
Armstrong against Lear, Administrator (with the will annexed) of Kosciuszko.
-A testamentary paper executed in a foreign country, even if executed so as to give it the effect of a last will and testament by the foreign law, cannot be made the foundation of a suit for a legacy in. the Courts of this country, until it has received prohate here, in the Court having the peculiar jurisdiction of the probate of wills and other testamentary matters.
■ APPEAL from the Circuit Court for the District of Columbia.
The bill, filed on.the..Chanc,ery side of the Circuit Court, stated, that Thaddeus Kosciuszko, on the 5th of May, 1798, placed a fund in the hands of Thomas Jefferson, and executed a will, as follows : “ I, Thaddeus Kosciuszko; being just on my departure from America, do hereby declare and
direct, that, should I make no other testamentary disposition óf my property in the United States, 1 hereby authorize my friend, Thomas Jefferson, to employ the whole thereof in purchasing negroes, from among his own, or any others, and giving them liberty in my name, in giving them an education in trade or otherwise, and in having them instructed for their new .condition in the duties of morality, which may make them good neighbours, good fathers or moders, husbands or wives, in their duty as citizens, teaching them to be defenders of their liberty and country, and of the good order of society, and in whatsoever may make them happy and useful. And I make the said Thomas Jefferson my executor of this. (Signed,) T. Kosciuszko. 5 May, 1798.”
Opinion of the Court — Mr. Justice Story
Primary OpinionMr. Justice Story
delivered the opinion of the Court.
The bill in this case is brought: against the administrator, with the will annexed, of General Kosciuszko, for the purpose of establishing a right of the plaintiff to receive payment out of the assets of the testator, of a certain bequest to him, contained in a supposed testamentary writing, executed by the testator at Paris, in France, in June, 1806. This supposed testamentary writing is set forth in the bill, and averred to be in the nature and of the effect of a last will or writing testamentary; but it does not appear to have been admitted to probate, either in France, or in the proper Orphan’s Court of this District. The answer admits the existence and authenticity of the instrument, and submits to the Court its import and legal effect, and whether it is to be deemed a last will and testament; and it also admits assets in the hands of the administrator sufficient to discharge the bequest. The cause was heard in the Court below upon the bill and answer, and from the decree dismissing the bill, the present appeal has been brought to this Court.
The cause has been argued here upon several points, involving a good deal of learning, and some doctrines of international law. We do not enter into an examination of thém, because rur judgment proceeds upon a single point, and will, in no event, prejudice the merits of the plaintiff’s claim.
By. the common law, the exclusive right to entertain jurisdiction over will's of personal estate, belongs to the ecclesiastical Courts ; and before any testamentary paper of personalty can be admitted in evidence, it must receive probate in those-Courts. Lord-Kenyon, in The King v. Inhabitants of Netherseal, (4 Term Rep. 258.) said, “we cannot receive any other evidence of there being a will in this case, than such as would be sufficient, in all other cases, where ti-ties are derived under a will; and nothing bub the probate or letters of administration, with the will annexed, are legaj evi(ience 0f the will, in all questions respecting personalty.11 This principle of the common Jaw is supposed to be in force in Maryland, from which this part of the District Of Columbia derives its jurisprudence; and the probate of wills of personalty to belong exclusively to the proper Orphan Court here, exercising ecclesiastical jurisdiction. If this be so, and nothing has been shown which leads us to a different conclusion, then it is indispensable to the plaintiff’s title, to procure, in the first instance, a regular probate of this testamentary paper in the Orphan’s Court of this District, and to set forth that fact in his bill. The treaty stipulations, the act of Congress, and the principles of the law of France, which have been cited at the argument, attributing to them the full force which that argument supposes to establish the validity of the instrument, do not change the forum which is entitled, by the local jurisprudence, to pronounce upon it as a testamentary paper, and to grant a probate. It is one thing to possess proofs, which may be sufficient to establish that a testamentary instrument had been executed in a foreign country, under circumstances which ought to give it legal effect here; and qurLe a different thing, to ascertain what is the proper tribunal here, by which those proofs may be examined, for the purpose of pronouncing a judicial sentence thereon.
For this reason, the decree of the Court below is to be affirmed, hut without prejudice, so that the instrument may be submitted to the decision of the proper Probate Court.