United States v. Barker
Syllabus & Case Posture
[Bills op Exchange.]
The United States against Priscilla Barker, Administratrix of Abraham Barker, deceased.
Wherever the government of the United States, through its lawfully authorized agents, becomes the holder of a bill of exchange, it is •bound to use the same diligence, in order to cnarge the endorser, as in a transaction between private individuals.
Where the United States were the holders of certain bills of exchange, and their agent in New-York was directed, by a letter from the Secretary of the Treasury, dated Washington, December 7th, 1814, to give notice of non-acceptance to the drawer and endorsers, residing in New-York, and notice was given to the endorser .on the 12th of the same month, the mail which left the 8th having arrived at New-York at 35 minutes past 10 o’clock, A. M. on the 10th: Held, that the endorser was discharged by the negligence of the holders.
So, also, where the United States were the holders of other bills, anu their agent in New-York was directed, by a letter from the Secretary of the Treasury, dated Washington, May 8th, 1815, to give notice of non-payment to the, drawer and endorsers residing in ' New-York, and notice was given to the endorser on the the 12th of the same month, the mail which left Washington on the i;th having reached New-York early on the morning of the .1th; held. that the endorser was discharged by the negligence of the holders.
ERROR to the Circuit Court for the Eastern District of Pennsylvania.
Opinion of the Court — Mr. Chief J ustice Marshal!,
Primary OpinionMr. Chief J ustice Marshal!,
delivered the opinion of the Court:
Thai whatever doubts might be entertained as to the charge of the Court below relating to the transactions in England, (which it has not been thought necessary to state,) in respect to the protest and transmission of the bills, we think there is none as to what took place after their arrival at the treasury of the United States. The (piestiou was, whether notice of the dishonour of the bills was transmitted to the party within the time prescribed by the general law in resp'ect to bills of exchange. The Court were of opinion, that there was negligence either at Washington or New-York, as to giving such notice; and that the notice actually given was too late to fix him with the responsibility. The letter from the treasury department giving the notice; was .either not sent in due course of mail to New-York, or there was negligence at New-York in not giving notice there as early as it should have been given, after the letter arrived at that city. Whether, therefore, the Judge erred or not, as to the first part of his charge, in respect to the transmission of the bills from England in a reasonable time, there was no doubt that the U idled States had no right to recover on account of the neglect in giving due notice after the return of the bills.
Upon, this ground, the judgment of the Circuit Cauri; was affirmed.