SCOTUS-Cases.net

Maguire v. Reardon

255 U.S. 271 1921-02-28 No. 202 624 Words
Full Case Caption
MAGUIRE ET AL. v. REARDON ET AL., AS COMMISSIONERS, CONSTITUTING THE BOARD OF PUBLIC WORKS OF THE CITY AND COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO, ET AL.
Official & Parallel Citations
255 U.S. 271 · 65 L. Ed. 625 · 41 S. Ct. 255
Court & Volume
Supreme Court of the United States · 255 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

MAGUIRE ET AL. v. REARDON ET AL., AS COMMISSIONERS, CONSTITUTING THE BOARD OF PUBLIC WORKS OF THE CITY AND COUNTY OF SAN FRANCISCO, ET AL.

ERROR TO THE DISTRICT COURT OF APPEAL OF THE STATE OF . CALIFORNIA IN AND FOR THE FIRST APPELLATE DISTRICT, DIVISION ONE.

No. 202.

Argued January 28, 1921.

Decided February 28, 1921.

The Fourteenth Amendment does not prevent a city from demolishing and removing wooden buildings, built within defined fire limits in face of prohibitory regulations in force at the time. P. 273.

Opinion of the Court — Me. Justice McReynolds

Primary Opinion

Me. Justice McReynolds

delivered the opinion of the court.

Defendants in error, officers and agents of the City and County of San Francisco, purporting to act under an ordinance approved May 8, 1917, gave notice of their intention to demolish and remove a wooden building on Van Ness Avenue, the property of plaintiffs in error. Thereupon the latter instituted this proceeding for an injunction upon the ground, among others, that as the building was lawfully erected the ordinance violated the Federal Constitution.

The court below, following Bancroft v. Goldberg, Bowen & Co., 166 California, 416, held that the building was erected in 1906 within the fire limits theretofore prescribed in violation of valid local regulations duly enacted under the charter, and consequently there could be no reasonable doubt of the municipality’s power to direct its removal.

The meaning and effect of the charter and ordinances thereunder are questions of local law determination of which by the state courts we commonly accept as conclusive. It is admitted that the building was constructed within defined fire limits, and the' Supreme Court of the State has said this was contrary to valid regulations then in force. The challenged ordinance must therefore be treated ás affecting an unlawful structure, and as so applied -we can find no plausible ground for holding it in conflict with the Federal Constitution. .

The judgment below is

Affirmed.

Cited By Later Decisions (1)

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).