SCOTUS-Cases.net

Archer v. Deneale

26 U.S. 585 1828-01 2,493 Words
Full Case Caption
John Archer and John W. Stump, Executors of John Stump, Complainants and Appellants, vs. Mary Deneale, Widow and Executrix of George Deneale deceased, Charles T. Stuart and Ann Lucretia his Wife, Mary Catharine and Nancy P. Deneale, Children and Representatives of the said George Deneale, Defendants and Appellees
Official & Parallel Citations
1 Pet. 585 · 26 U.S. 585 · 7 L. Ed. 272
Court & Volume
Supreme Court of the United States · 26 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

John Archer and John W. Stump, Executors of John Stump, Complainants and Appellants, vs. Mary Deneale, Widow and Executrix of George Deneale deceased, Charles T. Stuart and Ann Lucretia his Wife, Mary Catharine and Nancy P. Deneale, Children and Representatives of the said George Deneale, Defendants and Appellees.

The testator, residing and owning real and personal estate in the county of Alexandria, District of Columbia, by his will gave “ all his estate, real and . persois.il, to his wife during her life, for the use and purpose of raising arid educating his children,” each child at the age of twenty-one to be entitled to an equal portion of his estate, real andpersonal; subject, each, to a deduction of one-third for the maintenance of Ins wife. He recommends his wife to sell the negroes <br a term of years, and directs “ an appraisement” only of “his estate” shall be made, that no sale of the furniture shall be made ; arid then states that he is indebted to no one, and proposes to continue' so,” that he is surety for his brother, for which he holds á deed of tost on his property, sufficient, he'-'ho'pes, to pay-the same, and directs that his ■ “ estate shall not be' sold to pay these debts; until the property so divided shall be sold,” when his “estate must be charged with any deficiency, and directs that his executors shall not give security, as his own estate did not require it.” This will does not charge the real estate of the testator with his debts. {588}

The word “estate” is sufficiently comprehensive to embrace property of every description, and will charge lands with debts, if used with other words which indicate an intention "to charge them; but if used alone, without such intent, they will not have such operation. {589}

under the laws of Virginia relative to the estate of deceased persons, lands are never appraised. {589}

THIS was an appeal, by the. complainants, in a bill, filed in the Circuit Court for the county of Alexandria, - upon which a decree was rendered in favour of the defendants,” appellees in this Court.

. The complainants by their bill sought to make the real estate of George Deneale'liable for the payment of their debt. They set.forth, that-they ,have,a subsisting judgment against the ex--eculrix of George Deneale; for' the sum of §7957'58,, besides interest and costs. ■ That, this judgment, was founded bn a contract between James Deneale and George Deneale, and the testator of the complainants. That §2913 65. of this judgment. was satisfied by á sale of the property of James- Deneale the principal,,leaving, a balance.due on the judgment pf §5000.

Opinion of the Court — Mr. Chief Justice Marshall. delivered the opinion of the Court:—

Primary Opinion

Mr. Chief Justice Marshall.

delivered the opinion of the Court:—

This suit was brought in the Circuit Court for the District of Columbia, sitting in the county of Alexandria, to subject the lands of George Deneale to the payment of a debt for which he. was surety. The sole question arises on the construction of his will. The'complainants contend, that it charges his lands with his debts.

By his will, the testator gives to his wife “ all his estate real and personal, during .her life, for the use and purpose of raising and educating his children,' until they respectively are twenty-one.” He directs, that each child shall, at that age, become entitled to an equal portion of his estate, both real 'and personal, '“subject each to a deduction of one-third of the same,” to be retained for the support and maintenance of his wife. Jle recommends, to his wife, to sell the negroes for a term of years. He directs that an appraisement only of his estate “ shall be made, that no sale óf furniture' shall take place.”. He then states, that he is indebted to no'oné, and purposes to continue so. He states, that lie is Surety for his 'brother- James, for two sums, for which lie has a deed of trust on his property, sufficient, he-hopes,-to pay-the same. He then directs that his estate shall not be sold to páy these debts, until-the property so, deeded shall be sold, when -his estate-must be charged with any deficiency.' He directs that his executor and , executrix should not give security, as.his own debts did'not' requireit.,

That the word “ estate” is sufficiently' comprehensive to, embrace property of every description, and will charge, lands with' debts, if used with other words which indicate an intention to charge them, is a proposition which cannot be" contro-. ver.ted. As little.is it to be'denied, that the word alone, -if not used with an intent to subject the lands of the testator to the payment of his debts, cannot- have that effect.

In the will under consideration, thé t-éstator alludes in-two instances to his property, generally; in both hfe uses the-words “estate,” both “real and pérsonal.” In the next instance, the word estate is introduced alone,.in the clause which follows:

“ item, I do hereby direct,-that an appraisement only of my estate be made, and that no sale of furniture shall take .place.”

In Virginia, lands are nevér appraised, and the law directs a sale of all perishable, articles. When, therefore, the testator directs that an appraisement only of his estate be made, and that no. sale of furniture shall take plaoe, he obviously applies • the .term, exclusively, to that kind of property, the appraisement of which is directed by law, and is usual; and, by adding the word “ only,” restrains his executors from selling, that property which is directed by law to be sold. In this clause', the word estate is plainly confined to' personalty. He then -speaks of the debts for which he is- surety for Kis brother James, and directs that his “estate” shall not be sold to pay .these debts, until the property conveyed to,'him in trust shall be -exhausted. This direction is obviously restrictive. It restrains the executors from using a power'.they'possess under the'law. That power is to sell the personal estate for the payment of debts, but it does not extend to the sale of lands; con-sequently, the word estate, in this' place, also designates only personal estate. After this prohibition to sell his estate; until the trust property should bé all applied to the object, he adds, “ when my estate must -be charged with any deficiency.”

There is no foundation for the Opinion, that the testator has used the word estate, in this part of the sentence, in a.different sense from that in which it was used in the sume' sentence immediately before, while treating of the same subject. The. same estate, the sale'of which he had just forbidden until a particular event should take' place, must, he says,, be sold wheh that evént shall take place. He means only, his personal estate*

.Jt would, we think, be1 an entire perversion of the language used by the testator, to.construe these words a charge upon his'estate. He does not intend to create any liability, which thé law had not created. - When the trust property shall be exhausted, his estate, he says,' “must be charged with the deficiency.” He can no longer prevent its sale.'

We think- there is no error in. the decree, which declares* that-the will of George Deneale does not chárge his real estate with -his debts, and that the. bill of the complainants- be dis-, missed, with Costs, 'and that the said decree be affirmed.

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).