SCOTUS-Cases.net

United States v. Saline Bank

26 U.S. 100 1828-01 2,205 Words
Full Case Caption
The United States, Appellants, vs. The Saline Bank of Virginia, John Webster, and others, Appellees
Official & Parallel Citations
1 Pet. 100 · 26 U.S. 100 · 7 L. Ed. 69
Court & Volume
Supreme Court of the United States · 26 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

The United States, Appellants, vs. The Saline Bank of Virginia, John Webster, and others, Appellees.

The plaintiffs, as creditors of an unincorporated bank, filed a bill against the Cashier, and a number of persons, stockholders of the bank, for a discovery and relief; who, in reply to the bill, state, that their answers to the bill, would subject them to penalties, under the laws of Virginia, prohibiting unincorporated banks : held, that the defendants were not bound to make any discovery, which would expose them to penalties. {104}

THIS case came before the Court, on an appeal by the United States, from the decree of the District Court of the'United States, for the western district of Virginia; in which Court, the District Attorney of the United States, filed a bill against John Webster, Cashier, and a number of others, as stockholders of the Virginia Saline Bank, to charge them, in their private capacities, for certain deposits of money made with them, and also to subject their joint funds, Sec, ■

The bill charges, that about the year a company was formed by a number of persons, citizens of Virginia, within that district, to carry on the usual and ordinary business of banking. That they established a banking house — assumed the name and style of the “President, Directors, and Company of the Saline Bank of Virginia.” That they issued notes, or bills, purporting to be payable oiu of the joint funds — to make discounts and exchanges, whereby circulation and currency was given to their notes and bills. That in discharge of public dues, 10,120 dollars of their notes, were paid into the Treasury of the United States, before the 21st of October 1819; and, on that day, 5,831 dollars, in said notes, were deposited by an agent of the Treasury, with John Webster, Cashier of the said association, who demanded payment therefor, after obtaining a certificate of deposite; which payment was refused by Webster, who said he had no funds.

At the same time, the agent presented a .draft drawn by the Treasurer of the United States, for 4,290 dollars, being also for their notes received in the Treasury, which was the. balance of the said sum of 10,120 dollars. This draft was refused also, for want of funds. The bill charges, that Webster possessed funds of the company in specie and notes of solvent char ered banks, and combined with individuals of the company to .refuse payment, by fraudulently secreting these funds. The bill prays an account of the funds of the company, and also, to subject the Cashier and stockholders to a personal decree.

There was filed with the bill, the following documents mentioned therein:—

Opinion of the Court — Mr. Chief Justice MAitsiiALr,

Primary Opinion

Mr. Chief Justice MAitsiiALr,

delivered the opinion of the Court.—

This-is a bill in equity fora discovery and relief. The defendants set up a plea in bar, alleging that the discovery would subject them to penalties under the statute of Virginia.

The Court below decided in favour of the validity of the plea, and dismissed the bill.

It is apparent that in every step of the suit,, the. facts required to be discovered in support of this suit would expose the parties to danger. The rule clearly is, that a parly is not bound to make any discovery which would expose him to penalties, and this case falls within it.

The decree of the Court below is therefore affirmed.

Cited By Later Decisions (16)

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).