Conolly v. Taylor
Syllabus & Case Posture
James Conolly and others, Appellants vs. Richard Taylor and others, Appellees.
When there is no change of-ihe parties to a suit, during its progress, a jurisdiction depending on the condition of the parties, is governed by that condition as it was at the commencement of the suit. • [665]
If an alien should sue a citizen, and should omit to state the character of the patties in the bill, though the' Court tould not 'exercise jurisdiction while the "defect in the bill remained, yet it might, as is every day’s practice, be corrected at any time before the hearing, and the Court would :not hesitate to decree in'the cause. '.[565-]
The suit Was originally instituted by aliens and a citizen of the United States as complainants, against the defendants, citizens of the United States.' In the progress of the eause, and before ihe final hearing, the name of the citizen of the United States who was one of the plaintiffs was struck out .and he was made á defendant by the Court. It was he. i ¡ re substantial parties, plaintiffs, those, for whose benefit the decree is sought, are aliens, and the Court has original jurisdiction between them and all the defendants. ' But they-prevented the exercise of this jurisdiction by uniting with themselves a person-between whom and one of the defendants the Court could not take jurisdiction : strike out his name as a complainant, and the impediment is removed to the exercise of. that original jurisdiction which the. Court possessed between the alien parties, and all the' citizen defendants. There is no objection, founded on convenience or law, to this course. [¿65]'
THIS was an appeal from the circuit court of the United States, for the district of Kentucky, in which court the appellants were complainants, and the appellees were defend-;. ants.
In the circuit- court of Kentucky, on the 2Qth of February 1818, Thomas Conolly, James Conolly, Margaret Conolly, David David, and Francis Badley, aliené and subjects of the king of the united kingdoms of Great Britain and Ireland, and Samuel Mifflin, a citizen of tjie state of Pennsylvania, filed their bill against Certain-defendants, claiming to have an equitable title to a large tract, of lands in right of colonel John Conolly deceased, situated at the falls of Ohio, in the state-of Kentucky. The defendants in the bill were Richard Taylor, Fortunatus Cosby and Henry Clay, citizens of Kentucky, and William Lytle, described in the subpoena as a citizen of Kentucky, but who was in- fact a citizen of the state of Ohio. The.subpoena was served on all the defendants, Mr Lytle having been found by the process in Ken-, tucky.
Opinion of the Court — Mr Chief Justice Marshall
Primary OpinionMr Chief Justice Marshall
delivered the opinion of the Court.
As an objection was made to the jurisdiction of the-Court in this case, it may be proper, in order, to prevent a possible misunderstanding of the principle on which jurisdiction is sustained, briefly to state it.
The bill is filed in the court of the United States, sitting in Kentucky, by aliens and by a citizen of Pennsylvania. The. defendants are citizens of Kentucky, .except one who is a citizen of Ohio, on whom process was. served in Ohio. The jurisdiction of the court cannoj; be.questioned, so far as respects the alien- plaintiffs. As between the citizen of Pennsylvania and of Ohio, neither of them being a citizen of the state in which the suit was brought, the court could exercise no jurisdiction, Had the cause come , on for. a hearing in this state of parties, a decree could not have been made in it for the want of jurisdiction. The name of the citizen plaintiff, however, was struck out of the bilí be: fore the cause was brought before the court; and the question is, whether the., original defect was cured by‘this circumstance; whether the court, having jurisdiction over all the parties then in the cause, could make a decree.
The counsel for the defendants' maintain the negative of this question. ■ They contend that jurisdiction depends on the state of- the parties at.the commencement of the Suit; and that no subsequent change can giye or take it away. Th.ey' say, that if an alien becomes a citizen pending the suit, the jurisdiction which was once vested is'not divested by this circumstance. So, if a citizen sue a citizen of the samé state, he cannot give jurisdiction- by removing himself, and becomings a citizen.of á different state.
This .is true, but the court does riot understand, the principle to be, applicable to the case at bar. Where there is no changé-of party, a jurisdiction depending on the. Condition of the party is governed by that condition, as it was at' the commencement of the suit. The. court in the .first Case had complete original jurisdiction; in the last it had no jurisdiction either in form or substance. But if an alien should sue a citizen, and should omit-to state the.character of the parties in the bill: though the court could not exercise its. jurisdiction while .this defect in .-the bill remained ; yet it-might, as is every day’s practice; be corrected at any .tirrie before the hearing,' and the court would not hesitate to decree in the cause.
So in this case. The substantial parties plaintiffs, -those for whose benefit the-decree is fought, áre aliens ; ánd the. court has original jurisdiction bétween them .and all the de- ' fendánts. But they prevented the exercise of this jurisdiction, by uniting with themselves - a .person between whom and one’ of the defendants the-court cannot take jurisdiction. Strike out his. name as a complainant, and the impediment is removed to the exercise of that original'jurisdiction which the.court possessed, between the alien plaintiffs and all the citizen'defendants, ..We can perceive no objection/founded in convenience or in law, to this course.
Upon examining the - record, the judges are divided- in opinion on the question, whether the defendants; who . are-purchasers, have taken the lands charged' with the equity which was attached to it, while in .possession of .Campbell and his heirs; or are to be considered as purchasers without notice. It would be useless to state the arguments and facts .in support of each opinion. • The decree is affirmed by a divided Court.