SCOTUS-Cases.net

Ritchie v. Mauro

27 U.S. 243 1829-01 680 Words
Full Case Caption
John T. Ritchie, Appellant vs. Philip Mauro and Joseph Forrest, appellees
Official & Parallel Citations
2 Pet. 243 · 27 U.S. 243 · 7 L. Ed. 411
Court & Volume
Supreme Court of the United States · 27 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

John T. Ritchie, Appellant vs. Philip Mauro and Joseph Forrest, appellees.

The value of the interest a guardian has in the minor’s estate, is not the value-of the estate, but' that of the office of guardian. This is of ho value, except so far as it affords a compensation for labours and services; and in a controversy-between persons claiming adversely as guardians, having-no distinct interest of their own, it cannot be considered as amounting to a sufficient sum to authorise an appeal to this Cqurt, from a circuit court of the district of Co- ■ lumbia.

THIS was an appeal from the circuit court of the county of Washington; in which court the proceedings of the orphans’ court, of that county, appointing a guardian to the estate of a minor, had been reversed on appeal, and the court had proceeded to pass, such a decree, as it adjudged the orphans’ court should have ■ passed. From this decreé of the circuit court, the appellant came before this Court, and he sought to sustain the decision of the orphans’ fcourt.

The appellant, under an order of the orphans’ courti had béen appointed the guardian of John W. Ott; and had, in pursuance of the same, order, entered into a bond, as guardian of the said John W. Ott, in the petial sum of $10,000, with sureties.

‘ The' case was argued upon the whole of the matter contained in the decree, by Mr C. C- Lee and Mr Chambers, for the appellant; and. by Mr Bradley for the appellees.

Asj the Court did not decide but upon one of the points in the ca§e presented by the counsel, the arguments upon the others' are omitted.

Opinion of the Court — Mr Chief Justice Marshall

Primary Opinion

Mr Chief Justice Marshall

delivered the opinion of the Court.

In the present casé, a majority of the Court are of opinion that this Court has no jurisdiction in the case; the value in controversy not being sufficient to entitle the party by law to claim, an appeal. ., The value is not the value of the minor’s'estate, büt the value of the office of guardian. The present is a controversy merely between persons, claiming adversely as guardians, having no distinct interest of their own. The office of guardian is of no value; except so far as it affords a compensation for labour and servicés thereafter to be earned.

Cited By Later Decisions (2)

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).