United States v. Preston
Syllabus & Case Posture
The United States, Appellants vs. Isaac T. Preston, Attorney General of Louisiana, Appellee.
The offence against the law of. the United States, under the seventh section .of the.act of congress, passed the 2d of March 1807, entitled “ an act to prohibit the importation of slaves into any port or place within the jurisdiction of the United States from and after the 1st of January 1808,” is not that of importing or bringing into the United States persons of colour with intent to hold, or sell Such persons as slaves, but that of hovering on the coast of the United States with such intent; and although it forfeits the vessel and any goods or effects found on board, it is silent as to disposing of the coloured persons found on board, any further than to' impose a duty upon the officers of armed' vessels who make the capture to keep them safely, to be delivered to the overseers of the poor or the governor of the state or persons appointed- by the respective states to receive the same., [65]
The Josefa Segunda, having‘persons of colour On board of her, was, on the 11th of February .1818, found hovering oh the coast of the United States, and was seized and brought into New Orleans, and the .vessel and the persons ,on board were libelled in the district court of the United States of Louisiana, under the act of congress of the 2d of March 1807, After the decree of condemnation . below, but pending the appeal to this court,-the sheriff of New Orleans went on, with the consent of all the parties to the proceedings, to sell the persons of colour as slaves, and sixty-five thousand dollars, the proceeds, were deposited in the registry of the court to await the final disposal of the law.
By the tenth section of the act of 30th of April 1818, the six first sections of the act are repealed, and no provision is made by which the condition of the persons of colour found on board a vessel hovering on the coast of the United States is altered from that in which they were placed under the act of 1807, no power having been given to dispose of them otherwise than to appoint someone to receive them. The seventh section of the act of 1818 confirms no other sales previously or subsequently made under the state laws, but those for illegal importation, and does not comprise tjje case of a condemnation under the seventh section.
The final condemnation of the persons on board the Josefa Segunda took place • in this court on the 13th-of March 1820, after congress had passed the act of the 3d of March 1819, entitled “ an act in addition to an act prohibiting the slave trade,” by the provisions of which persons of colour brought in under any of the acts prohibiting traffic in slaves, were to be delivered to the president of the United States to be sent to Africa. It could not affect them.
In admiralty cases a decree is not final while an appeal from the same is depending in this court, and any statute which governs the case must be an existing valid statute at the time of affirming the decree below. If, therefore the persons of colour, who were on board the Josefa Segunda when captured, had been specifically before the court on the 13th of March 1820, they must have been delivered up to the president of the United States to be sent to Africa, under the provisions of the act of the 3d of March 1819, and therefore there is no claim to the proceeds of their sale, under the law of Louisiana, which appropriated the same. The court do not mean to intimate that the United States are entitled to the money, for'they had no power to sell the persons of colour. m .
Opinion of the Court — Mr Justice Johnson
Primary OpinionMr Justice Johnson
delivered the Opinion of the Court.
The case of the Josefa Segunda has been twice already before this court: the first time upon the question of condemnation ; the second, upon the application of several claimants to be preferred in the distribution of the proceeds.
It now comes up upon a claim to the proceeds of the sale of. the persons of colour found oh board at the time of the seizure, interposed by the law officer of the state of Louisiana.
The vessel was condemned under the sevénth section of the act of 1807, passed to abolish the slave trade. By the fourth section of the act, the state of Louisiana was empowered to pass laws for disposing of such persons of colour as should be imported or brought into that state, in violation of that law., The offence under the seventh section, on which this condemnation was founded, is not that of importing or bringing into the United States, but that of hovering on the coast with intent to bring in, persons of colour to be disposed of as slaves, contrary to law; and although it forfeits the vessel and any goods or effects found on board, it is silent as to disposing of the coloured persons found on board, any farther. than to impose a duty upon officers of armed vessels, who may capture them, to keep them safely, to be delivered to the overseers of the poor, or the governor of the state, or persons appointed by the respective states to receive the same.
The state of Louisiana passed an act on the 13th of March 1818, which recites the provisions of the fourth and seventh sections of the acts of congress, and authorises and requires the sheriff of New Orleans to receive any coloured persons designated under, either of those sections, and the same to keep, until the district or circuit court of the United Státes shall pronounce a decree upon the charge of illegal importation.
The second section makes provision for selling them upon receiving a certificate of such decision, and enjoins a distribution of the proceeds; one ha If to the commanding officer of the capturing vessel, the other to the treasurer of the charity hospital of New Orleans.
In pursuance of this law of the state, it appears, that after the decree of condemnation below, but pending the appeal in this court, the sheriff went on to sell, with the consent, it is said, of all parties; and $65,000, the sum now in controversy, was deposited in the registry of the court below, to await the final disposal of the law.
The 20th of April 1818, congress passed another act on this subject, by the tenth section of which, the six first sections of the act of 1807 are repealed.; but their provisions are re-enacted with a little more amplitude; and the fifth section of this act, which professes to reserve to the states the powers given in the former act, as well as the language of the repealing clause, in the saving which it contains as to offences; still confines all their provisions to the case of illegal importation; thus leaving the seventh section in force, but without any express power to dispose of the coloured persons, otherwise than to appoint some one to receive them.
. And so likewise the seventh section of the act of 1818, which professes' to confirm sales previously or subsequently made under the state laws, confines its provisions to sales made under condemnation for illegal importation; thus not comprising the cases of condemnation under the seventh section of the act of 1807, at least so far as relates to this offence.
The final condemnation, in this court took place March 13th, 1820; but previous to that time was passed the act of March 3d, 1819, entitled, an act in addition to an act, prohibiting the slave trade; by which a new arrangement is made as to the disposal of persons of colour seized and brought in under any of the acts prohibiting the traffic in slaves. By the latter act, thejr are deliverable to the orders of thb president; not of the states. And the renealing clause fépeáls all acts and parts of acts which may be repugnant to this act. So- that if in the disposal of persons of colour brought into the United States, the provisions of this act embrace the case of such persons when brought in under the seventh section of the ,act of 1807, the power to deliver them to the order of the states was taken away before the final decree' jn this court.
Such,dn the opinion of the court, is the effect of the act of 1819. And then the question is, how does it affect tlWpreSent controversy.
. Ever since the case óf Teat on vs. The United States, 5 Cranch, 286, . the court has uniformly acted under the rule established in that cáse^jto witT that in admiralty causes a decree was notfmab while it was depending here. And any statute which governs the case, must be an existing, valid statute, at the time of affirming the decree below.
Whatever was the extent of the legal power of the state, over the Africans, it is clear that such power could not be exercised finally over them at any time previous i.0 the final decree of this court; we must therefore consider, whether, if they had been specifically before the court at the date of that decree, they must have been delivered up to the state, or the United States: clearly to the United States. And then this claim of the state cannot be sustained.' We would not be understood to intimate, that the United States are entitled to this money; for they had no power to sell. . Nor do we feel, ourselves- bound to remove the difficulties which grow out of this state of things. .
With regard to the ground of irregularity.: if notabandoned by the attorney general, it was but slightly touched upon, and we know of no other mode in the existing.state of things, in which the rights of the parties could be reached, according to the course of the admiralty, but that here pursued.
On the question whether the decision in the second cause, in which the subject of. this seizure was before us, was not final as to the rights of the United States, we are clearly of opinion, that it was not, as against this party. Although this question might then have been raised by the state, and could as well then have been- settled; yet it was not raised, nor was it the interest of any of the parties then before the court, that it should be raised.
The decree below must be reversed.
This eáuse came on to be heard on the transcript of the record from the circuit court of the United States for the eastern district of Louisiana, and was argued by counsel; on consideration whereof, it is ordered, and decreed by this court, that the decree of the said district court in this cause be,' and the same is hereby reversed, and that the said cause be, and the same is hereby remanded for further proceedings to be had therein according to law and justice, and in conformity to the opinion of this court.