Conard v. Nicoll
Syllabus & Case Posture
John Conard, Marshal of the Eastern District of Pennsylvania, Plaintiff in Error vs. Francis H. Nicoll, Defendant in Error.
The principles decided in the case of Conard vs. The Atlantic Insurance Company, relative to the priority of the United States, examined and confirmed.
ERROR to the circuit court of the eastern district of Pennsylvania.
The defendant in error brought an action of trespass, in the court below, against the plaintiff in error, for a quantity of merchandize, consisting of teas, cassia, nankeens, &c. all of the value of one hundred and ninety-three thousand seven hundred and twenty-five dollars. Also for four ships, viz. the Addison, the Woodrop Sims, the Thomas Scattergood, and the Benjamin Rush, all of the value of one hundred thousand dollars.
The defendant below pleaded, that he, as marshal of the district of Pennsylvania, had a writ of fieri facias against one Edward Thomson, in favour of the United States, and that he seized the merchandize and ships as Thomson’s property. The plaintiff replied, property in himself, &c. in the common form.
It was agreed between the parties to the suit, that the title of Francis H. Nicoll. to the property should be tried, the property having been placed in the hands of trustees, to abide the event of the suit.
Opinion of the Court — Mr Justice Baldwin
Primary OpinionMr Justice Baldwin
delivered the opinion of the Court.
This cause has been submitted without argument; It is in all its leading features, both in the points of law which arose and the evidence given at the trial, so similar to the case of Conard vs. The Atlantic Insurance Company, decided by this court at January term 1828, 1 Peters, 386, that we do not think it necessary to enter into an examination of the principles on which the judge submitted the cause to the jury. They appear to us to be in perfect accordance with the opinion delivered in that case, on great deliberation; of the entire correctness of which we do not entertain a doubt.
There is no error in the record of the circuit court, and the judgment is affirmed, with six per cent interest and costs.