SCOTUS-Cases.net

Jackson ex dem. Bradstreet v. Thomas

29 U.S. 102 1830-01 2,369 Words
Full Case Caption
Ex Parte Martha Bradstreet; in the Matter of James Jackson ex dem. Martha Bradstreet vs. Daniel Thomas
Official & Parallel Citations
4 Pet. 102 · 29 U.S. 102 · 7 L. Ed. 796
Court & Volume
Supreme Court of the United States · 29 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

Ex Parte Martha Bradstreet; in the Matter of James Jackson ex dem. Martha Bradstreet vs. Daniel Thomas.

A rule had been granted on the district judge of the northern-district of New York, to show cause why he did not sign a bill of exceptions in a case tried before him. The court said, that on the day of the return, of the rule, the district judge has a right to show cause; whether the person who obtained the rule moves or not. He has a right to have the rule disposed of.

On the trial of a cause in the district court of the United States, for the northern ■ district of New York, exceptions were taken to opinions of the court delivered in the course of the trial; and some time after the trial was over, a bill of exceptions was tendered to the district judge, which he refused to sign, objecting to some of the matters stated in the same, and at the same time altering the bill then tendered, so as to conform to his recollection of the facts of the case, and inserting in the bill all that he deemed proper to be contained in the same ; which hill of exceptions, thus altered, was signed by the judge. On the motion of the party who had tendered the bill of exceptions, a rule was granted on the district judge, to show cause why he did not sign the bill of exceptions as first tendered to him. To this rule the judge returned his reasons for refusing to sign the bill so tendered, and stating that he had signed such a bill of exceptions as he considered correct.

By the Court. This is not a case in which the judge has refused to sign a bill of exceptions. The judge has signed such a bill as he thinks correct. The object of the rule is to oblige the judge tó sign a particular bill of exceptions which has been offered to him. The court granted the rule to show cause ; and the judge has shown cause, by saying he has done all that can be required from him, and that the bill offered is not such a bill as he can sign. The court cannot order him to sign such a bill.

A return by the district judge to a rule ,o show cause, need not be sworn to by him. [103]

The law requires that a bill of exceptions should be tendered at the trial. If a party intends to take a bill of exceptions, h¿ should give notice to the judge at the trial; and if he does not file it at the trial, he should move the judge to assign a reasonable time within • which he may file it. A practice to sign it after the term, must be undeistood to be matter of consent between the parties; unless the judge has made an express order in the term, allowing such a peiiod to prepare it.

Opinion of the Court — Mr Chief Justice Marshall,

Primary Opinion

Mr Chief Justice Marshall,

delivered the opinion of the Court.

The court is unanimously of opinion that the rule ought not to be granted.

This is not a case in which the judge has refused to sign a bill of exceptions. The judge has signed such a bill as he thinks correct. If the court .had granted a rule upon the district judge to sign a bill of exceptions, the judge could have returned that he had performed that duty. But the . object of the rule is, to oblige the judge to sign a particular bill of exceptions, which had been offered to him. The court granted the rule to show cause; and the judge has shown cause, by saying he has done all that can- be required from him; and that the bill offered to him is not such a bill'as he can sign-

. Nothing can be more manifest, than that the court cannot order him,to sign such ¿bill of exceptions. The person who offers a bill of exceptions ought to present such a one as the judge can sign. The course to be pursued is, eithér to endeavour to draw up a bill, by agreement, which the judge can sign; or to prepare a bill to which there will be no objection, and present it to the judge.

The court will observe, that there is something in this proceeding which they cannot, and which they ought not to sanction. A bill of exceptions is handed to the judge several weeks after the trial of the cause, and he is asked to correct it from memory. The law requires that a bill of exceptions should be tendered at the trial. But the usual practice is to request the judge to note down in writing the exceptions, and afterwardsj during the session of the court, to hand him the bill of exceptions, and submit it to his correction from his notes. If he is to resort to his memory, it should be handed to, him immediately, or in a reasonable time after the trial. It would be dangerous to allow a bill of exceptions of matters dependent on memory, at a distant period, when he may not accurately recollect them- And the judge ought not to allow it.

If the party intends to take a bill óf exceptions, he should give notice to the judge at the trial; and if he does not file it at the trial, he should move the judge to assign a reasonable time within which he may file it. A practice to sign it after the term must be understood to be a matter of consent between the parties, unless the judge has made an express order in the term, allowing such' a period to prepare it.

It is ordered by the court that the mandamus as prayed for be, and the same is hereby refused; and that , the rule heretofore granted in this cause be. and the same is hereby discharged.

Cited By Later Decisions (8)

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).