SCOTUS-Cases.net

Reynolds v. Cooper

291 U.S. 192 1934-01-15 No. 227 291 Words
Full Case Caption
REYNOLDS, COLLECTOR OF INTERNAL REVENUE, v. RICHARD F. COOPER
Official & Parallel Citations
291 U.S. 192 · 78 L. Ed. 725 · 54 S. Ct. 356
Court & Volume
Supreme Court of the United States · 291 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

REYNOLDS, COLLECTOR OF INTERNAL REVENUE, v. RICHARD F. COOPER.

No. 227.

Argued December 11, 1933.

Decided January 15, 1934.

Mr. Erwin N. Griswold, with whom Solicitor General Biggs, Mr. Sewall Key, and Miss Helen R. Carloss were on the brief, for petitioner.

Mr. N. E. Corthell, with whom Mr. A. W. McCollough was on the brief, for respondents.

Opinion of the Court — Mr. Justice McReynolds

Primary Opinion

Mr. Justice McReynolds

delivered the opinion of the Court.

In each of these causes a beneficiary received from trustees royalties arising from a lease of oil and gas lands. in Wyoming. Taxes were exacted upon the full amounts so received. Separate ■ suits were brought to recover proper allowances for depletion. The respondents prevailed in both of the courts below. Here the causes were heard together.

The Solicitor General says — “ The question is identical with that raised in Helvering v. Falk, No. 225, October Term, 1933, and the argument made in the Government’s brief in that case is likewise applicable here. . . . There is therefore substantially no difference between the position of the beneficiaries in this case and the Falk case.”

The judgments below are affirmed upon authority of Helvering v. Falk, decided this day, ante, p. 183.

Affirmed.

Mr. Justice Brandeis, Mr. Justice Stone, and Mr. Justice Cardozo think that these cases are to be distinguished from No. 225, Helvering y. Falk, just decided, because of the nature of the duties imposed upon the trustees, and of the remainder interest granted to the beneficiaries by the trust instrument presently involved, and accordingly concur in the result.

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).