SCOTUS-Cases.net

Brown v. Van Braam

3 U.S. 344 1797-02-13 6,088 Words
Full Case Caption
Brown versus Van Braam
Official & Parallel Citations
3 Dall. 344 · 3 U.S. 344 · 1 L. Ed. 629
Court & Volume
Supreme Court of the United States · 3 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

Brown versus Van Braam.

ERROR from the Circuit Court, for the Diftritft of Rhode IJland. The cafe was as follows: On the 10th of March, 1792, Brown and Francis, merchants, of Providence, in Rhode IJland, drew four fets of bills of exchange on Tho-?nas Dickafon and Go, merchants, of London, payable at 365 days fight, to Benjatnin Page, or order, for the aggregate fum of f. 3000 fterling. Page being át Canton on the 28th of March, 1793, endorfed thefe bills to Fan Braam, the Defendant in error, and on the fáme day, as the agent of Brown' and Francis, drew another fet of bills of exchange, upon Thomas. Dickafon and Co. payable, alfo, at 365 days fight, to Van Braam, or order, for f, 3000 fterling. On the 9th oif " April; Í793, Page,, in the fame character of agent, drew a fi-milar fet of bills, in favor of Van Braam, or order, for £. 40a fterling. One bill of each fet was prefented to Thomas Dicka-fon and Co. in London, for acceptance, on the 31ft oí December, 1793, but were then protefted for' non-acceptance, of which Brown'¿nd Francis had notice on the I ft of Jnly,i 7 94, though the bill? and protefts were not actually returned to them. The-bills were again prefented for payment on the 15th of January, 1795, (that is days after they were actually due) and protefted for non-payment, of which Brown and Francis had notice on the iftof April, 1795. This a£tion,was inftituted in the Circuit Cour.t of November Term, 1796, to recover the amount of the protefted bills, with intejeft, damages and charges ; and the declaration contained a fpecial count on each bill, together with a’ general indebitatus affumpftt for 40,000 dollars, money had and received by the-Defendants, fo the ufe of the Plaintiff. ‘On the return of the record it appeared,, that Francis had died fubfequent to the fervice of the original writ; that Brown .came into court ,and, after fuggefting the death of Francis, pleaded the general iffue; and that the Plaintiff haying, likewife', fuggefted the death of Francis K prayed 'judgment againft John Brown, the furviving- Defendant.” There was no joinder in iffue, continuance, or-other pleading; but immediately after the above prayer for judgment, the record proceeds, in this form : “ And the i£fd Join Bmvn made .de- “ fault:' Whereupon, this caufe being iubmitted to the court, “ and the court having fully heard the parties by their counfd; “ and mature deliberation being thereon had, it is conjidered “ by the court now here, that the fair! Andreal E. Fan Braam “Houchgeeft, do recover againfi the .laid John B.-nun, the “ furviving partner as aforefaid, the fum of thirty four thou* ’ “ fatid four hundred and fifty five dollars, and tyrentv fi'ven cents damages, and coils of fuit, taxed at fixreen dollars and <£ fifiy two cents.” To the record of t'‘is judgment, the following memorandum was annexed : “ Nota Bene. The above “ fum, as ordered by the court, includes the principal and in- “ to reft from the 15th January, T795, to the 19A November, “ 1796, and ten per cent damages, and twenty nine dollars, “ and twenty two cents, charges of proteft.”

Upon this record the following errors were afiigned, and argu-'d by Howell and Robbins, of Rhode ljland, and Dexter, of Mcjfachvfetts, for the Plaintiff in error, and by .Barnes, of Rhode Ifiand, and Mifflin, of Pennfylvania, for the I)efendant in error.

ill. That after plea pleaded,, there was a difcontinuance of the caufe in the court below,and, therefore,.no judgment could be rendered.

2d. That 10 per cent; damages, and 6 per cent; intereil, are included in the judgment, where no damages at all ought to -have been given.

3d. That the court affeffed the damages, when they ought to have be.en aflefled by ?. jurv.

Opinion of the Court — WILSoN Jujilce,

Primary Opinion

On the

WILSoN Jujilce,

delivered the opinion of the court. - - - - -

B~ THE COURT :-We are ~inani~oufIy of oprnion, that under the laws, and the praaical conifrualon bf the courts, of Rhode Ijiand) the judgment of the Circuit Court.ought to be affirmed.

`With refpe& to the entry of this affirmauce, intereft is to be calculated to the prefent time, upon the aggregate fum of principal and intereft in the judgment below; but no further. We cannot extend the calculation to rune Term next, when the mandate will operate in the Circuit Court, as the party ha~ a right to pay the money immediately. -

The Judgment affirmed, with Jingle coffs.

SUPREME COURT,

February i3th, I 797.

R U L E.

IT is Ordered, by the Court, That the Clerk of the Court to which any Writ of Error thall be dire&ed, may make return of the fame, by tranfn~itting a true copy of t~e Record, and of. the Proceedings in the Caufe, under his hand, ~nd the Seal of the Court.

C~IASE, ~fuflice, obferyed, that he concurred in the opinion of the court; but that it was on common law principles, and not in compliance with .~he laws and practice of the ftate.

Cited By Later Decisions (4)

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).