Clarke v. Russel
Syllabus & Case Posture
Clarke versus Russel.
IN Error from the Circuit Court, for the Diftrhft of Rhode-If and. Ón the return of the Record, it appeared that a declaration, containing the following Count, had been filed in an a<Sion brought by “ Nathaniel Rujfel of Charlefon, in the Diftridi of South-Carolina, merchant and citizen of the State of South-Carolina, againft John Innes Gldrke of Providence-, in the County of Providence and. Diftriit of Rhode-If and, .merchant and citizen of the-State of Rhode- Ifand, and fur-viving partner of the company of Jofeph Nightingale, now deCea'fed, and the faid John Innes Clarke, heretofore doing bu-finefs under the firm of Clarke and Nightingale
lit Cthint. “ That the faid John Innes Clarke and Jofeph K 'Nightingale,.then in full life, on the 10th day of.March 1796, “ at the DiftriiS of Rhode-If and, in confideration that the Plaintiff would at the (pedal .inftance arid requeft of the M faid .Jofeph and John Innes, indorfe feven feveral fetts of “ bills of Exchange, of the daté, tenor, and defcription as-fet. ‘c forth in the annexed fchedule, drawn by a certain Jonathan “ Rujfel, who was agent and partner in that particular of « the company of Robert Murray and company, of New- “ York, in' the DiftriiS of New-York, on themfelves affirmed, ■ “ and to the Plaintiff faithfully promifed, that if the faid bills “ íhóuld not be paid by the.perfon on whom the f^me were drawn, and. the Plaintiff, in ctmfequencé of fuch endorfe- “ ment fhould be obliged to pay the fame bills, with damages, .w cofts, and intereft thereon, they the faid Jofeph and Johrl “ Innes would well and truly pay to the Plaintiff the amount M of the faid bills, damages, and- cofts, and intereft, if the Draw- “ er of faid bills did not pay the fame to the faid Plaintiff “■ And the faid Plaintiff in fadt faith that in confideration of, “ and truffing to, the faid affumption and promife,hedid indorfo “ the faid bills : and the fajd Plaintiff further in fadt faith that the.perfon, on whom the faid bills were drawn, did not ac- “ cept,'Or pay the faid bills, but that the faid bills were, in due “ form of'law, protefted for non-payment, of which non-pay-. ⅞ ment and proteft, notice was given in due form of law to the “ drawer thereof, and alfo to the Plaintiff, to wit, on the 13:!* tc day.of September, J796, at faid Diftridt of Rhode-Ifand,by “ reafon whereof, in confequence of faid indorfement, the “ -Plaintiff was obliged to pay the faid bill', with damage’s, cofts tc and intereft thereon, amounting to ,£.474.4., 13, 1.. flerling <c money of'Great Britain* equal in value to 2,0,338 dollars u and'52 cents, and adtually did pay the fum of money laft 4C mentioned, in difcharge of the faid bills, before the com- “ mencement of this fuit, to wit, on the laid 1.3th day of Sep-*l terrber, 1796, at'the Driftrift of Rhode-IJlgnd, aforefaid, of ‘c which the drawer of- the faid bills, on the day, and year, and “ at the Diftndt laft aforefaid had notice, and the fafrd, drawer <c was then,. and there requefted by the Plaintiff to pav to <c him the fum of money laft aforefaid', which he, the (aid draw-<c er, refufed tó do, of all which the faid Jofeph and John Innes, .<c afterwards,' to wit, on the day and year laft aforefaid, at the “ Diftrict aforefaid, bad notice, Nevertheless, &c.”
The Defendant pleaded‘'«i« affumfft.; and thereupon iffue was joined* On the trial the Jury found for the Plaintiff on the firft Couqt, with 22,839 dollars and 80 cents damages ; and for the Defendant on all the other Counts in the declaration. On this verdidl judgment was rendered; but. the Defendant-having filed a bill of exceptions; brought the préfent Writ of Error. The bill of exceptions was founded on the following feafons,.which it fet forth’at large: .
■ lft. That upon the trial of the iffue “ the Counfel learned “ in the law for the faid Nathaniel Rujfel to maintain and ⅛ prove the faid iffue, offered in evidence the aforefaid foreign “ bills of exchange, with protefts for non-payment, but with- “ out any protefts for non-acceptance of the fame, or of' any “ of them.”
2d. That “ the faid Counfel alfo contended, and infifted be- “ fore the Jury, that- two -letters of Clarke and Nightingale,: A directed, to the Plaintiff, and dated January 2,0th, and 2i/?. “ 1796, did import, an engagement, or promifo by the faid * Clarke. Nightingale to the Plaintiff,’that the faid Robert 51 Murray & Co. would fully comply with any contracts oreniC gagemeiits they might make with the Plaintiff.
Opinion of the Court
Primary OpinionThe opinion of the Court, after lome days deliberation; was delivered by the Chief Juftice, .in the following terms; •
■ Eelsworth, Chief JaJUcc. This caufe comes up on a bill of exceptions,.on the face of vvh'ch three exceptions appear.
1. Firll, that bills of exchange, which had been non-accepted,’ and protefted for non-payment, were admitted in evidence unaccompanied by protejis for non-acceptance'.
According to a'general rule, laid down by this Court; in the cafe of Barry and Brown, from Virginia, .and from which rule there'appear no fpecial circumftances to' exempt the prefent. cafe, this exception will not Hold;
2. A further exception is, that the Judge in his charge to the Jury, held, that the two letters from the Defendants to the Plaintiff below, of the 20th and '21ft of- January 1796, which werefetup to’prove an undertaking, or guarrantee, might ⅜ explained by parol tcjlimony ; of which kind of teftimony fonie had palled to the jury, without objedliojn, but for what purpofe does not now appear,, as there were divers Counts; feme of which parol teftimony might have fupported.
The undertaking declared upon, in the Count, to which the verdidl applies, being for the duty of another, it muft; to fave it from the llatute of frauds, and.perjuries, be in writing, and wholly fo. The. two letters, therefore, yvhicH are’ relied upon as th$ written agreement, cannot be added to, or varied, by pa-rol teftimony. Nor can they be fo far explained by parol tefti-mony, as to affedl their import, with regard to the fuppoled Undertaking. The charge then, of the Judge, that “ they might be explained by parol teftimony,” expreffed as a general rule, and without any qualifications, or reftri&ions, was too broad ; and may have milled the .jury. . On this ground there muff be a reverfal. •
3. It is, therefore, unneceffary to decide the remaining quef-tioir—Whether the two letters did, of themfelve.s, import an undertaking, or guarrantee ? It may be proper to fuggeft, however, that a majority of the Court, at prcfent, incline to the opinion that they do not.
Judgment reverfed, and a Venire de novo awarded.
I h^tve undei’floodj that the CnirV Jcjt/ce, and Clshíno rJuf»P€^ ■were for the affirmative and I:;t un i,, Paterson*, and WashinIgA tost, jujures, were for the negative, ap-fwer, on the third queftioin