Glass v. The Sloop Betsey
Syllabus & Case Posture
Glass, et al. Appellants, versus The Sloop Betsey, et al.
1794.
CAPTAIN Pierre frc~de 7ohannene~ the comifiander of a French privateer, called the Citizen Genet, ha.viiig cap- tured as prize, on the high feas, the flo6p Betfey, lent the veiTeI into Baltimore; but upon her arrival there, the owners of the iioop and her cargo filed a libel in the Diftria Court of Mary~- land, claiming reftitution, becaufe the veffel belonged to fubje&s of the king of Sweden, a n~utra1 power, and the cargo was owned, jointly by Swedes ai~d Americans. The captor filed a plea to the j'uiifdi~ion of tt,e court, which, after argument, was allowed ; the Circuit Court aflirn-ted the decree; and, thereupon~ the r~refent a~oea1 was itiffttuted.
The generaFqueftkn~vas-Mrj~ether under the c~rcumftan- ces of this cafe, an ArneriéaivCouft of Adthiralty, h~s ju~i1d~c- tion to entertain the complaint, or libel, of the owners~ and to decree reffitution of the property ? It was argued by E. Ti/gb- man and Lewis, for the ~pp~I1aiits ; andby lPincbejler (of ~fd- ryid,zd) and The Poncean, for the aj~p~11ee.
For the App ~#ant.ç the cafe was lrie~y opened.1 upon the ~ol~ lowing princi'ples~ rfhe quelUon is of great irnportaflce; and extends to the whole judIci~1 authority of the U~te4 States ; for, if the admiralty h~s no jurifdi~io~i, there can be no jurif-. d~&ion in an~ common l~w court. Not is it-material to dif- tinguifh the o~ierthip of the veffel and cargo; fince ftrangers, or al~ens, in amity, are entitled equally with Americans to navc their property protected by the laws. Vatt. B. 2. f. 101, 103. p. 267. There can be no doubt that this ~s a ~ivi1 caufe of ad- nHi;aILy and maritime jurifdiaion~ z~d fo within the very terms ofthe judi~ia1 a&. rtefdtution, or iio. reftitution, is the lead- in~ point; that nece11~ri1y, indeed~ involves the point of prizes orno Prize, as a 4efence for capturing but if the admiralty is once fairly poffeiTed of a caufe, i~ ha~ a ri~tht to try every ~1nCi- dental q~e~-ion~ That the veffel is a 1e~a1 prize, ~iiay be a good plea. to the fuit; but it is no~a good plea ~o the jqrildk- tion of the court; and the captor ~y br~ng~ng his prize ~ito an Arnarican port1 has blinfeif fubmitted co the American iurifdic- tion, which is in this inftance to be exercifed by the ~Judicia1, flit the Executive, department. Const. U. S. art. 3. s. 1. Jud. Act. f. 9. Doug. 580, 84, 5. 592. 4. Carth. 474. 1 Sid. 320. 3 T. Rep. 344. 4 T. Rep. 394, 5. Skyn. 59. T. Ray. 473. Carth. 32 6 Vin Abr. 515. 3 Bl. Com. 108. 1 Vent. 173. 2 Saund. 259 2 Keeb. 829. Lev. 25. Sid. 320. 4. Inst. 152. 154. 2 Bulsh. 27, 8, 9. 2 Vern. 592. 3 Bl. C. 108 2 L. Jenk. 755 727 733 751 754 755 780.
For the Appellees, the captors (after some exceptions to the regularity of the appeal, which were waved by consent) it was observed, that this is not a libel for a trespass, and so within the jurisdiction of the District Court; because a seizure as prize, is no trespass, though it may be wrongful. Nor can any act subsequent to the seizure for securing and bringing the prize into port, give jurisdiction, if the seizure does not. Doug, 571. Neither can the question be, whether the taking was to illegal as to amount to piracy; and therefore, that there ought to be restitution; for piracy can only be decided in the Circuit Court. But the question raised by the libel is a question of prize; and the decision of that must precede the subsequent one of restitution; which, so far from being the main and original question, is the consequence of the former. Admitting, then, the present capture to be unlawful, because it is neutral property, still the District Court has no jurisdiction of a question of prize by the constitution and laws of the United States, nor by the laws of nations.
Opinion of the Court — THE COURT, BY THE COURT;
Primary OpinionTHE COURT,
having keptthe caufe under advifement for feveral days, informed the counfel, that befídes thé queftion of jurifdidtipn as to the Diftrict Court,, another quefti.on fairly arofeupon the record,—whether any foreign nation had a right, without the pofitive ftipulations'of a treaty, to eftablifh in this country, an admiralty jurifdidfion for taking cognizance of prizes captured on the high feas, by\ its fubjedts or citizens, from its enemies ? Though this queftion had not been agitat- ; ed,.the Court deemed it of great public importance to be decided; and,meaning to decide it, they declared a defire 4o' hear it difcufléd. Du Ponceau, however, obfcrved, that the parties to the-appeal did .not conceive themfelves ¡ntérefted in the point; and that the French minifter had given no inftrUc-tions for arguing it. Upon which, Jay, Chief fuf ice, pro-, ceeded to deliver the following unanimous opinion.
BY THE COURT;
The Judges being decidedly of opinion, that every District Court in the United States, possesses all the powers of a court of Admiralty, whether considered as an instance, or as a prize court, and that the plea of the aforesaid Appellee, Pierre Arcade Johannene, to the jurisdiction of the District Court of Maryland, is insufficient: THEREFORE IT IS CONSIDERED by the Supreme Court aforesaid, and now finally decreed and adjudged by the same, that the said plea be, and the fame is hereby overruled and dismissed, and that the decree of the said District Court of Maryland, founded thereon, be, and the same is hereby revoked, reversed and annulled.
And the said Supreme Court being further clearly of opinion, that the District Court of Maryland aforesaid, has jurisdiction competent to enquire, and to decide, whether, in the present case, restitution ought to be made to the claimants, or either of them, in whole or in part (that is whether such restitution can be made consistently with the laws of nations and the treaties and laws of the United States) THEREFORE IT IS ORDERED AND ADJUDGED that the said District Court of Maryland do proceed to determine upon the libel of the said Alexander S. Glass, and others, agreeably to law and right, the said plea to the jurisdiction of the said court, notwithstanding.
And the laid Supreme Court being further of opinion, that no foreign power can of right institute, or erect, any court of judicature of any kind, within the jurisdiction of the United States, but such only as may be warranted by, and be in pursuance of treaties, it is therefore decreed and adjudged that the admiralty jurisdiction, which has been exercised in the United States by the Consuls of France, not being so warranted, is not of right.
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED by the said Supreme Court, that this cause be, and it is hereby, remanded to the District Court, for the Maryland District, for a final decision, and that the several parties to the same do each pay their own softs.