Hills v. Ross
Syllabus & Case Posture
Hills et al Plaintiffs in Error; versus Ross.
THIS was a writ of error diredted to the Circuit Court for ■ the'Diftridt of Georgia. On the return of the record, feveral errors were affigned; but the only one, now .relied on, ftated “ that the fadts on which the Circuit Court had founded their decree, did not appear fully upon the record, either from the pleadings and decree itfelf, or a ilate of the cafe agreed to by the parties, or their council, or by a ftating of the cafe by the court/’ as required by rh'e 19th fedlion of .the judiciary adt.'
On examining this record, it was found, that noftatement of fadts had been made either by the court or the parties, nor did it appear from the pleadings and decree, upon what fadts the decree of the Circuit Court had been founded. But it appeared, that a number .of witneffes - had been produced and fworn, (the record did not fay examined) at the hearing before the Circuit Court, whofe teftimony had not been committed to writing; while, on the other band, the depofitions of the wit-neffes who had been examined before the Dijlriii Court, were annexed to the proceedings returned. It was acknowledged by the council for the Defendants in error, that the teftimony of the witneffes produced in the Circuit Court, had been taken viva voce, according to the 30th fedlion of the judiciary adt, and that their depofitions had not been committed to -writing. It was conceded by the council on both fides, that without other aids than fuch as were to be derived from this imperfedT record, it would be impoffible to obtain a fair review of- the proceepings of the Circuit. Court in this caufe. But Cox and J>/ponceau, for the Plaintiffs in error, contended for a reverfal off the decree. Reed (of South Carolina) E. lilghman and Levels for the Defendants, infilled on the other hand, that the decree ought to be affirmed, unlefs it was fhewn to be erroneous ; that the omiffion on which the Plaintiffs relied, could not be affigned as an error, and did not vitiate the proceedings ; that it was to be afcribed to the negleft of the Plaintiffs them-felves, who ought, in the firíl inilance, to have applied to the adverfe council to ílace a cale, and if they refufed, or difagreed in their ilatement, then to the court itfelf; that the Defendants ■ being fatisfied with the decree and not • intend.ng to appeal .therefrom, it was not their bufmefs to alíiíl t Plaintiffs in perfefting their record, foas to enable them to bring it properly before an Appellate Court. Upon the whole, they prayed that the decree be affirmed.
For. the Plaintiffs in error,
it was infilled, that the omiffion of a ilatement of the cafe, vitiated the whole record. The judiciary aft of the United States had -greatly innovated upon the old fyilem of Admiralty and Chancery proceedings, the forms and princ'- les of the common law were interwoven with,, and in many caies, entirely 'fubftituted to thofe of the Roman jurifprudence. The- 30th leftion of that aft required, that the teilimony of witneffes iaculd be taken viva voce, inilead of written depoiitions, both in the Diílrift ai d the Circuit Court. In the former of thtfe tribunals, indeed, when either of the parties expj-effed an intention, of appealing ;to the other, the depoiitions' of the witneffes were to be committed to writing, but this cafe wits an exception to the general rule. In the Circuit Court, where new evidence was admitted, no provifioa ’ had been made for committing the teilimony to writing,.except • in the cafe of abfer.t, aged, infirm or departing witneffes, whofe evidence might be taken de bene cjft, prccifely as in the. comimon law courts. The whole teilimony, therefore, could not, without the confent of parties, come before the Supreme' Court of -the United'States, in any cafe where new witneffes were heard, or the. feme witneffes who were examined below, were produced de novo before the Circuit Court.
It was clear, that the intention of Congrefs was to veil the powerof trying matters of fail in Admiralty and Equity cafes,in the Diílrift and Circuit Courts exclufively. Like the ver-diftof a jury, the decifion of the latter tribunal, was final and conelufive, as tofaft. - 'The Supreme Court were only empowered. to cs.rreft their decrees in matters of law. Therefore an appeal did not lie to them, but only a writ of error, asatcom--mon law. And by the 22d feftion of the judiciary aft, it was ' provided, that no decree of the Circuit Courts ihould be re-verfed for any error in fail.
Opinion of the Court — The Court
Primary OpinionThe Court
were, unanimoufly5 of opinion, that the error afiigned, was not a' fuififcient ground for reverfing the degree, and recommended to the parties to come to fame .agreement, which might bring the matters in controveriy fairly before them.
After fome converfátion, an agreement took place between the council oh both lides,'' that tne caufe ihould be continued" to the next term ; apd that, ia the mean time, new evidence might be taken pn both fules, arid the whole rhatter of fa<&, as well as the law, brought before the Supreme Court.of tha United States, as upon an appeal.
See-the famticafc ¡nfl .