SCOTUS-Cases.net

M'Kee's Leffee v. Pfout

3 U.S. 486 1798-12 1,895 Words
Full Case Caption
M'Kee's Leffee versus Pfout
Official & Parallel Citations
3 Dall. 486 · 3 U.S. 486
Court & Volume
Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · 3 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

M'Kee’s Leffee versus Pfout.

THIS was an ejectment tried at the Nifi Prius for Dauphin county in October 1795, when a verdict was given for the Leffor of the Plaintiff, fubject to the opinion of the Court, on a cafe, ftating the following facts.

On the third of January 1794, a warrant had iffued for the lands defcribed in the declaration in favor of James Chambers; who, on the 6th of January 1758, made his will, and, inter alia, devifed, “that ail his eftate, after' payment of his debts, be equal- “ ly divided between his wife Sarah, and his children Rowland, “ jinn, Sarah, James, Elizabeth, Benjamin, and .J'ofeph, each “ one eighth part." The Leffor of the Plaintiff claimed one eighth part of the premifes under the .teftator’s daughter Ann, who had intermarried, twenty years ago, with Oliver Ramfay, by whom (he had iflue, and' died. Before her death, however, oil the 23nd of Oflober 1779, fhe had joined, with fame of the other devifees, in conveying their refpeiSive ihares in the eftate, for a valuable consideration, to Andrew Str.oui, the real. De-ftndant j but, at the time of executing the conveyance (touching which, fhe was feparately examined by a Judge of Dauphin county) ihe had iseen driven away Oy her hufaand, and lived ieparate from him ;—.a fa£l with which the Leffor of the Plaintiff was well acquainted. On the *ftof Qdtober. 17.85, Oliver. Ramfay (wjio is ftill' living) executed an indenture between him and the Leffor of the Plaintiff, wherein it is fet forth, “that “the faid Oliver hath granted, bargained, fold, aliened, releafed, “ enfeoffed and Confirmed, and doth grant, bargain, fell, alien, “ releafa, enfeoff and confirm, unto Robert M’-Kee, in his ac~ “ tual poffeftton now being, by virtue of a bargain and fide to “ him made, by the faid Oliver, as thefe prefartts, and by vir- “ tue of the ftatute, for transferring ufes into poffeffion, and to his heirs and alfigns, wzy undivided part and refpeéiive ihare “ and purparts of him the faid Oliver Ramfay, of, in and to “ that certain piece or tract of land, before defcribed, with all “ and fingular ways &c.' and rcverfions' and remainders. “and alfo all the eftate, right', title, intereft, claim and dé- “ man'd, whether at law or in equity, of him the faid Oliver, “ of, in and to the fame, to have and to hold the faid refpeélive “ ihare and purpart, of in and to the faid plantation, and tract “ of land, hereditaments, and premifes, hereby granted, mentioned or intended to be, with the appurtenances, unto “ the faid Robert MdKee, To the only proper ufe, benefit and be-u hoof of them the faid Robert M-Kce, his heirs, and affigns Mforever. And the faid Oliver Ram/dy for himfelf, his heirs, “ executors and adminiftrators, not jointly, do covenant, proa “ mife, and grant to and with the faid Robert MlRee, his heirs “ and affigns. That he the faid Oliver Ramfay, hath not done “ or committed any a<ft, matter, deed, or thing whatfoeyer* “ whereby or wherewith his faid and refpeélive ihare and purpart of, in, and to the faid piece or traift of land, heredi- “ taments, and premifes, are or fhall or may be impeached^ “ charged or incumbered, in title, charge, eftate, or otherwife “ howfoever. And the faid Oliver, for himfelf, his heirs, ex- “ ecutors, and adminiftrators, not jointly, do covenant, promife, “ and grant, to and with the faid Robert Mf-Kee, his heirs and M affigns, that the faid Oliver, his heirs, executors andadmiriif- “ trators, his ihare and purpart,.of him the faid Oliver Ram-“fay, of, in, and to, the piece or trail of land aforefaid, heredi-' “ taments and premifes, againft them, their, and each and every “ of his heirs and affigns, and all and every perfon.and perfons “ whatfoever, lawfully claiming, or to claim by from or tinder “ him, or either of them, his or any of his heirs tr affigns fhall* ‘‘ and will warrant, and forever defend by thefe preients. And “ that faid Oliver, and his heirs, not jointly, do further “covenant, promife, and grant, to and with the faid Robert,. “ that they, him, hervor any of them, fliall and will, at anytime or times hereafter, at and upon the reafonable requeft, proper “ cofts and charges, in law, of the faid Robert MiKee, his heirs “ or affigns, make, execute and acknowledge, Or caufe fo to be, “ all, and every fuch" further and other reafonable act or ails,- “ deed or dee'ds, device or devices, in the law whatfoever* either “ by fine or recovery, or otherwife howfoever, for the further “■ and better conveyance, afi’urarice a,nd confirmation cf his “ refpeélive ihare and purpart of him the faid Oliver, of in and “ to the faid piece/or traél of land aforefaid, hereditaments, and u premifes, unto'the fai'd Robert, his heirs, r¿nd affigns, as by “ him or them, or his or their counfel learned in the law, ihaH “ be reafonably advifed, devifed, nr Required.” *

There is no confideration mentioned inTnis deed ; but there was a feparate receipt for ¿.6a, given by Olive- Riimfdy to Robert MlKee-y and the deed was acknowledged, and recórdec, on the day of its date.

. The general queftion fubmitted to the Court, was—whether a conveyance in fee% by a tenant by the curtefy, is not a forfeiture of-his eftate ? And it was argued by Tngerfolty for the Lef-íor.óf the Plaintiff, and by Dúncan^nvid C. Smithy for the Defendant.

For the Leffor of the Plaintiff.

Opinion of the Court — M‘Kean, Chief JtiJlice.

Primary Opinion

The Court flopped Ingerfoll, when he was about to reply, 'and delivered their opinion as follows.

M‘Kean, Chief JtiJlice.

We entertain no doubt on the prefent queilion. Tne Legiflature has, at various periods, and on a variety of fubjetfts, departed from feudal ceremonies and principles, in relation to the transfer and defeent of property: but, in the. prefent inftance, the ail of Aflembly meant only to give to a grant of lands, a greater effeil upon the eftate, on recording the deed, than could previo fly have been enjoyed, without livery of feizen; It never contemplated that ci.rcum-ilunce, as an inftiument to work a forfeiture, on the common law doftrine of alienation bv tenant for life, or years.

.Shippen, Jyflice. F ro n the words of the ail of Aflembly., it is plain, I think, that the Legiflature did not mean to work the forfeiture of a particular eftate, by the provifion for recording deeds. In allowing to deeds recorded the fame torce and effeit, as feoffments with livery, the intention is exprefslv re-ftrifled to “giving poffeffion and feifen, and making good the title and aflurance of lands, tenements, and hereditaments.

It is, therefore, merely a facility and benefit extended to the grantee.

Yeates and Smith, JaJlices, concurred.

Judgment for the Plaintiff.

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).