SCOTUS-Cases.net

Olney v. Arnold

3 U.S. 308 1796-08 5,864 Words
Full Case Caption
Olney versus Arnold
Official & Parallel Citations
3 Dall. 308 · 3 U.S. 308 · 1 L. Ed. 614
Court & Volume
Supreme Court of the United States · 3 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

Olney versus Arnold.

THIS was a wat of error on a judgment given in the Sit- . perior Court of Judicature, court of áflize arid jail deli-livery, for the county oiProvidence, in the State of Rhode IJl-t and; and the cafe, appearing, on the record, was as follows' 'Olney, the Plaintiff in error, was the colledtor of impolts for. Rhode IJland; Arnold, the 'Defendant in error, was owner of the' ihip Neptune; arid a citizen' of the name of Bexter, as the declaration ¿Hedged, was owner of the cargo of the' Ihip ; which arrived from Surinam, at Providence, about°4 o’clock' P. M. on the (>th of. November, 1792.'' On that day, the parties applied for a permit"to landthe cargo, ánd. offered bonds to pay the duties; but the colleofor refufed, or negledted, to accept the bonds and grant the permit. On the 7th of November, afecond ápplication was made for a permit;, and bonds, actually executed, were tendered for the payment of the duties ; but the collector again peremptorily' refufed to'accept the bonds, or to' grant the permit; in confequeuce of which the veflel, with the cargo on board, remained at á heavy expence from the'ótb to the 13th of November-, and Arnold laid his damages at ^200. >

Qlney, the Defendant in the court below,

pleaded that by the Aift'fe&ion of the adt of Congrefs, paifed on the 4th of Augujl, 3:790, “ to provide more effectually for the’ coll eft ion of the duties, &c ” it is declared that all duties on goods, wares and merchandise imported, ihall be paid, or fecured tobe paid, before a permit ihall be granted for landing the fame and that “ no perfon whofe bond for the payment of duties is due and unfatisfied, ihall be allowed a future credit for duties, until fucli bond ihall be fully paid, Or difchargcd that on the 17th of January, 179•¡f Arnold being indebted for duties, gave a bond for the amount, payable on the 17th of May, enfuing ; that on the 5th of November 1792, the term for payment of the bond was elapfed, but the fame then remained unpaid and undif-charged ; that Arnold was the real owner of the cargo, but had fraudulently transferred it to Dexter, in order to obtain a credit at the Cuftom-houfe; that, though Dexter had tendered a bond-on the 7th of November, it was rejected by virtue of the recited aft of Congrefs ; and that a permit had been refufed until the duties of the cargo were paid, or Arnold's old bond was difeharged.

To this plea-the Plaintiff below demurred, and ailigned the following caufesofderhurrer: iff, Becaufe the matters contained in the plea might be given in evidence, if at all, under the general iffue ; and they amount to no more than the general iffue- 2d, Becaufe the plea ftates the property of the cargo to • be in Arnold, and does not traverfe the property of Dexter therein. ■ 3d, Becaufe it does not appear that the old bond given by Arnold was unfatisfied after the 5th of November 1792. 4th,.Becaufe the bond given by Arnold was for his'own proper debt, and the-bond tendered.by Dexter was for his own proper debt: And 5th, b.ecaufe the plea is inccmfiftent, uncertain, not •iffuable, and wants form.

The .Defendant joined in demurrerand, thereupon, the Court of Common Fleas, for the'Courrfy of Providence, decided that the plea.was afuiKcient bar to the aftioiV; and, in December X792, gave judgment for the Defendant accordingly. From this judgment the Plaintiff appealed to the fuperior court of judicature, where it was adjudged,-in December 1794, that the plea in bar was not fufficient; arid the caufe was remitted-to the County Court for trial. On the trial, the Jury gave a verdift for the Plaintiff, damages /13 ef. With colts:' and the Defendant below brought,die prefent writ of error, to .remove the proceedings into the Supreme Court-of the United States ⅛ the conftruftion. and validity of the aft of Congrcfsj under which the Defendant juftified, being involved in the decifion of the State Court. Confutation of the United States, art. 3. f ?. Laws of the United States, 1 ml. -ft. 6g. f. 25.

Opinion of the Court — By the Court

Primary Opinion

By the Court

:—We are clearly of opinion, that the Superior Court of Rhode If and, on whofe judgment this writ of error is brought, is the higheft court of law of that ftate, within the meaning of the 25th feftion of the judicial aft. The general aflembly might fet afide, but they could not make, a decifion. ' ’

The.Chief Justice then .delivered the opinion of the court on' the firft point;.,in confeqúence of which, the judg-merit of the fuperior court of Rhode If and, was affirmed.

Chase, Juftice. The citation may' likewife be ligneil by a juftice; qf'this court.

Lee, Attorney General. 7'rúe ; but the aft contemplates giviag aa i-.teyuuttve to aceo-uynoclate the party.

Cited By Later Decisions (2)

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).