SCOTUS-Cases.net

Pemberton's Leffee v. Hicks

3 U.S. 479 1798-12 3,133 Words
Full Case Caption
Pemberton's Leffee versus Hicks
Official & Parallel Citations
3 Dall. 479 · 3 U.S. 479
Court & Volume
Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · 3 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

Pemberton’s Leffee versus Hicks.

THIS ejectment was tried at Newtown, in Bucks County, May, 1794, when the Jury found the following fpecial verdict:

■ “ The Jurors impannelled, tried, fworn and affirmed to try “ the iffue joined in this caufe- upo 1 their" refpedtive oaths and “ affirmations fay—That Laurence Grouden, being feized in fee “ of the premifes in the declaration mentioned, by his laft will in “ writing duly made and executed, devifed the fame premifes in fee fimple to his daughter Grace Galloway, then the wife of “ Jofeph Galloway, and afterwards died leized thereof as afore- “ faid : That the faid Grace Galloway had iftue by her faid « hufband, one daughter Elizabeth, who is ftill alive : That “ the faid Jofeph Galloway afterwards by A<ft of Affembly “ paffed on the 6th of March 1778, was required to furrender “ himfelf under pain of being attainted, of High Treafon 1 “ That the faid Jofeph Galloway did not furrender him- “ felf accordingly, and therefore became and ftood attainted oí a High Treafon to all intents and purpofes, and his eftate for- “ feited to the commonwealth, the faid- .Grace Galloway then “ being in full life : That the (aid premifes were afterwards du~ a 1 y feized and fold by the agents for forfeited eftates, and the a fame conveyed to the Defendant by the commonwealth. “ That the faid Jofeph Galloway fo being attainted, departed out of the United States into parts beyond fea, and ftill “ continues there in full life : That the faid Grace Galloway ‘‘.continued in the United States, and afterwards, to wit, on the “ 6th Feb. 1782, died feized in fee dimple of the premifes * aforefaid, having firft, to wit, on the 20th Dec. 1781, duly ‘‘ made and publiihed her laft will in writing, whereby “ ihe devifed the' faid premifes to Owen Jones and others;-. “ That the furvivors of the faid devifees afterwards, to wit, on the 6th of April 1790, conveyed the fame premifes to “ Thomas Rogers That the faid Thomas Rogers on the 20th “ April 1790, conveyed the fame premifes to the Leffor of “ the Plaintiff, who demifed the fame premifes to the fame “ Richard Fenn : That the fame Richard Fenn entered and A was oufted ■ by the faid Defendant.

“ If upon thefe fa£ts the law be with the Plaintiff* they find “ for the Plaintiff and affefs fix pence damages, befides the “ cofts; but if for the Defendant they find for the Defendant.”

The general queftion was, whether a tenant by the courtefy initiate, has an eftate forfeitable upon his attainder for treafon ? And it was argued at two feveral terms, by E• Tilghman. arid Leivis, fot the Leffor of the Plaintiff} and by Ingerfoll and Dallas, for the Defendant*

For the Lejfor of the Plaintiff,

Opinion of the Court

Primary Opinion

. If tenancy by the curtefy initiate is an effate of any kind.; if it gives any inter ejf in the lands;—if it gives any title to the tenant; then is it- afubjeft of forfeiture, under the pofitive provifions of the aft of Aftembly. It is evident, that the forfeiture under this aft is more extenfive, than by the common law, or ftatutes, of England. 1 H. If- P- C. 24.2. In England the forfeiture is of lands arid tenements of inheritance, and rights of entry; and the profits of lands and tenements, which the attainted per-fon had in his own right for life, or for years: 4 Bl. C, 381. But here, in addition to thefe objefts, rights of entry touching lands, a right to reverie a judgment, and all conditions, ufes, and trufts, aré forfeited, if, therefore, a tenancy by the cur-tefy initiate is forfeited by attainder in England, a fortiori it is forfeited in Prnnfylvania. ■ -

Cur. Adv. Vult.

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).