United States v. Fries
Syllabus & Case Posture
The United States versus Fries.
INDICTMENT- for Tréafcm fey -levying virar, againft the United States, at Bethlehem, in the County of Northampton. The Pi ifoner, after a trial that lafted fifteen days, was con viewed : whereupon Lewis and Dallas⅜ his Counfel, moved for a hew trial, on two general'gro'unds.
1ft. That there had been a mif-trial. ■
id. That there had not been an unbiajjed and impartial trial. I. The fadfs on the firft ground, appeared to be thefe: A venire, tefted .the lithof October, 1798, .and returnable the lithof Jpril, 1799, had iifued, by which the Marihal was Commanded_to fummon 24 Grand-Jurors, and “ a number of , uhoneft and lawful men of your laid diftrift, riot Ids than “ forty-eight, and not exceeding Jixty, to ferve as petit,-jurors/’ • Annexed to this Vmire, the Marihal, in due form, made a re- ■ turn of the whole number of fixty jurors, all of whom were .fummoned from the City and County of Philadelphia: And ona ftpatafe paper, figned by him, he returned an additional ritlmber of 17 jurors, fummoned from the County of Northampton, and of 1⅞ jurors, fummoned from the County of Bucks ; making, in the whole, 89 jurors. For this latter return, however, no Venire had iiTued, nor did any fpecial award appear on the Record; and the jury that tried the Prifoner, was com-pofed of jurors from Philadelphia, Northampton, and Bucks.
On thefe fadts, the Prifoner’s Counfel made the following points:
That although it was notufual to grant a new trial inacapi-* tal cafe, it was, unqeftionably, in the power of the Court to do it. 3 Bl. Com. 391- I Burr. 394. 2 Sir a. 968. 6 Co. 14.
Opinion of the Court — Peters, DijlriSi Judge,
Primary OpinionPeters, DijlriSi Judge,
did not think, that either objection ought to prevail. He thought that the venire, and returns of the jurors, were authorifed by principle and precedent; and that the declarations of Rhodes were fueh as might naturally be made in relation to the infurredtion, without m,ani-fefting á particular hoftility towards the prifoner, or leading to a convidtoh in fpite of any evidence, or argument, that might occur on the trial As, however, the confcquence of dividing the Court, would be a rejection of the motion ; and as the inte-refts of public juftice, and the influence of public example, would not be impaired by the delay of a new trial, the District Judge determined to acquiefce in the opinion of Judge Irepe£1. •
A new trial awarded. .