SCOTUS-Cases.net

United States v. La Vengeance

3 U.S. 297 1796-08 2,080 Words
Full Case Caption
The United States versus La Vengeance
Official & Parallel Citations
3 Dall. 297 · 3 U.S. 297 · 1 L. Ed. 610
Court & Volume
Supreme Court of the United States · 3 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

The United States versus La Vengeance.

ERROR from the Circuit Court for the diilrifl: of New York. - It appeared on the return of the record, that La Vengeance,' a French privateer, had captured and carried into New York, a Spanijb'lhip, called La Princejfa de AJlnrias; and that thereupon Don Diego Pintardo, the owner of the prize, filed a Libel in the Diilridt Court, complaining of the capture; alledging that La Vengeance- was illegally.fitted out within the United States; and praying reftitution and damages: ■ but on a claim, exhibited in behalf of the owners of the privateer, the Diftridl Court difmiiled the Libel with coilsand, upon appeal to the Circuit Court, that decree was ¡affirmed. The fate of Pintardq's Libpl determined, likewife, the fate of an information filed cx officio, by the Diftridl Attorney, claiming the privateer as a forfeture, upon the fame allegation, that ihe had been illegally armed and equipped in the United States, in violation of the adl of Congrefs: and. in both. thefe d'ecifions the parties-acquiefced.

But a third proceeding had been inilituted againft the pri-* vateer, in which the Diilricl Attorney filed, cx officio, an information, Rating “ that Aquila Giles, Marihal of the fáid di Arrice, had fe i zed to the ufe of the United States, as forfeited, a certain fchooner, or veiled, called La Vengeance, with her tackle, apparel, and furniture, the property of fome perfon, or perfons, to the faid Attorney unknown; for that certain cannons, muikets, and gun-powder, to wit,-* 2 cannon, 20 muíkets, and 50 boxes of gun-powder, were between the-23d oí'‘May, 1794, and the 22J oí May, 1795, exported in . the faid fchooner, or vejfel,from the faid United States, to nuit, from Sandy-Hook, in the Jiate of Nevj Jerfey (that is to fay, from the city of New York in the New York diftridt) to a foreign country, to wit, to Port-de-Paix, in the ifland of St. Domingo, \in the Weft-Indies, contrary to the prohibitions of the a£t, in fuch cafe made and provided,’* &e: And praying judgment of forfeiture accordingly. A claim was filed on behalf of the owners of the privateer, denying the exportation of cannon or múíkets; and alledging that the gun-powder coniH-tuted part of the equipment of the Semillante, a'frigate belong--ing to the Republic of France, and had been takenfrom her and put on board .the privateer, to be carried to Port-de-Paix, by order of the proper officer of the faid Republic. It was, alfo, alledged, that the fchooner, after her arrival at Port-de-Paix, was bona fide fold to one Jaques Rouge, a citizen of the French Republic, in whofe behalf the. claim was in'flituted.

After argument, the District Judge decreed, that the fchooner flaould be forfeited j but, upon appeal to the Circuit Court, the decree was rev$rfed, and Judge .Chace certified that the judgment of reverftll was founded on the following fades :—“ i ft. That front 18 to 20 muikets, were carried in the faid fchooner La ftengeance in the month of March or April, 1795, from the United States of America, to a foreign country, to wit, to Pert-de-Paix, in the. Weft Indies', But that fuch muikets were the private property of French paflengers on boards of the faid fchooner, carried out for their own ufe, and not by way of merchandize.”—2d. “ That upwards of 40 boxes of gun-powder were carried at the fame time, from the faid United States, in the laid fchooner to Port-de-Paix, afore-' laid : But that fuch gun-powder was taken from on board the S’-milliante frigate, lying in the harbour of New York, was a part of hot equipment, did not appear ever to have been landed in the faid United States, was carried out for the ufe of the French "Republic, was delivered to'the commander in chief at Pórt-de-Paix—;and was not exported wav of trade r merchandize.”

From this judgment of the1 Circuit- Court-, a writ of error was brought on behalf of the-United States, the general errors were affigned, and the Defmdnat in error pleaded in nullo eft erratum. The ¡flue was- argued on the loth of Augvft, by Lee, Attorney General of the United States, for the Plaintiff in error, and by Du Ponceau, for the Defendant but no exception was taken, by the former, in reference to the merits ofthecaufe.

Lee, Attorney General

Opinion of the Court — By the Court.

Primary Opinion

By the Court.

Weate.perfeilly fatisfied upon the two points that have been agitated in this caufe. In the firflr place, wc think, that it is a caufe of Admiralty and Maritime Jurif-diclion. The exportation of arms and ammunition is, limply, the offence ; and exportation is entirely a water tranfadlion. It appears, indeed, on the face of the libel, to have commenced at Sandy Hook-, which, certainly, mult have been upon the water. In the next place, we are unanimouily of opinion, that it is a civil caufe-: It is a procefs of the nature of a libel in rem ; and does not, in any degree, touch the perfon of the offender. •

In this' view of the fubjeil, it follows, of courfe, that no jury was neceffary, as it was a civil caufe ; and that the-appeal to the Circuit Court was regular, as it was a caufe of Admiralty and Maritime jurifdiilion.—Therefore,

Let the decree of the Circuit Court be affirmed with cojis.

But on opening the court the next day, the chief justice directed the words “ with coils” to be ilruck out of .the entry, as there appeared to have been fome caufe for the profe-, cution. He'obfervéd, however, that, in doing this, the Court did not mean to be underlldod, as, at all, deciding.the queftion, whether, in any cafe, they could award coils againll the United States 5 but left it entirely open for future difeuffion-

Cited By Later Decisions (12)

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).