SCOTUS-Cases.net

Wiscart v. Dauchy

3 U.S. 321 1796-08 4,438 Words
Full Case Caption
Wiscart, et al. Plaintiffs in Error, versus Dauchy, Defendant in Error
Official & Parallel Citations
3 Dall. 321 · 3 U.S. 321 · 1 L. Ed. 619
Court & Volume
Supreme Court of the United States · 3 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

Wiscart, et al. Plaintiffs in Error, versus Dauchy, Defendant in Error.

ERROR to the Circuit for the Virginia Diftrift. ' The original proceeding was on the Equity fide of the Court below, where the Defendant in Error had filed a bill, charging Adrian Wfcart and Augujline De Neufuille, Co-partners,-wirh having fraudulently conveyed all their eftate, real and;perfonal, by three (aparate deeds, to Peter Robert De iteufuille (who was alfo made a.Defendant to the bill) with a view to prevent the;Complainant’s recova ing the amount of a decree, which lie had formerly obtained in another fuit againft them. The an-; fwers averred the conveyances to be made bona fide, ar.u for a .valuable confideration ; but after a full hearing of the cafe, the Cjrcuit Court (confiding of Judges Iredell and Griffin) delivered, the following opinion: That the deeds filed as exhibits in this raufe, one dated on the 20th oflvlav, 1793,convey-ing the goods and chattels in the fcnedule thereunto annexed, to the Defendant P. R, De Neufiuille ;—another dated on the 17th of the fame month, conveying the ilavgs therein mentioned, to.the faid P. fi. De Neufviile ;---and another, dated on the 20th day of the fame month, conveying to him the land therein mentioned,- are fraudulent, and were intended to defraud the complainant, and to prevent his obtaining fatisfadfion for a juft demand ; that the faid P. R. De Neufviile was. a party and privy to the fraud aforefaid ; and that the faid Deeds were void as to the Complainant: Whereupon it is decreed and ordered, ~ the cireumftances of each particular QaL~ and every fuitor is entitled by the Conf'citutibn to have it. re-examined in this Court. i Burr. ~96. 484. - ~very equivocal fa~ may be ex-. p~1ainedby circumft~nces; and thofe circuinftances fhould ap-. pear wherever the fa& is to be made the ground.ofa judicial decifion. But here the Decree not only f~at~s the general re- luJ.t that the .L)eeds were traudulent, but that they were made with a view to defeat and defraud a juff creditor, without fpe- cifying by what evidence the fraudulent intention was afcer- tamed. if it was o~Iy giving a preference to another banafide `creditor. the A~ could not be deemed fraudulent; and. this Court ought not to b~ bound by the conftru&ion of an inferior `~o~rt~ asto that point, but thould exercite their own ju~g_ ment upon a knowledge ofnll the fa6Is. Ttce Decree, thérefore~ ought not in any cafe to be deemed conclufive; and in this cafes at all events, it is not luch ajtatement as the law contemplates, but the fcaternent, on which the ca~fe is now to be ~ake~i up~ muit be that WhiCh, reciting the eviuence an~ exbibits is ex- prefsly called a ftatement, and as fu ch is fubfcribe4. by the

that the said Deeds be by him, the said P. R. De Neusville, delivered to the Clerk of this Court, to be cancelled ; that when thereunto required, he deliver up to the Marshall of this Court, so much of the personal property in the said Deeds mentioned, or either of them, as is now in his hands or possession, to the end that the Complainant may have an execution thereon; that he do account before one of the Commissioners of this Court for the value of all the personal property mentioned in the said Deeds, or either of them, which he shall not be able to deliver from having disposed thereof, or from any other cause. And it is further ordered, that the Defendants pay to the Complainant his costs by him expended in the prosecution of this suit." The record being returned containing the above Decree, at large, and all the pleadings, and depositions, and examinations, produced and taken in the cause the discussion by Ingersoll, for the Defendant in errors and by Lee and Du Ponceau for the Plaintiff, involved these considerations,-Whether a statement of acts by the Circuit Court was in any case conclusive? And whether the Decree, in the present case was such a statement of facts as the law contemplated ?

For the Defendant in error. The Court may state the case, in conformity to the Act of Congress (Jud, Act f. 19 1 vol. p.60.) by merely sending-forward the evidence. In Talbot v. Fanson, ant. p. 138. in not: and Hills et al. v. Ross ant.p. 184. there was no statement be the Circuit Court, and the question now agitated was started ;but the Counsel, in deference to what seemed to be the opinion of the Bench, waved the objection, and proceeded upon the evidence at large, as transmitted with the record.

The present case turns upon the point, whether the execution of certain Deeds was, or was not, fraudulent ? but, surely, the Decree of the Circuit Court, declaring the execution to be fraudulent is not a statement of the facts, but an inference of law arising from the facts. It must have been the design of the Legislature to separate the fact from the inference; otherwise this court would be precluded from examining on appeal, the justice of the inference, compared with the facts, from which it had been drawn by an inferior tribunal. The statement called for by The Act, may, indeed be likened to a special verdict, where the Jury-ascertain the fans, and the Judges decide the law arising from them; and it cannot be denied, that a question of fraud, or not, is a question of law, the result of

Judge. I~'or the Plaintiff in error. `1~here is no precedeht to bind the decifion of the Court;. and, therefore, the gei~uine expo- iition of the a~ic of Congrels is to be lought as the onJy guide on this occafion~ Two things are in~c1uded in the record-~ lit. The Pleadings and U,ecree; and 2d. The Statement of the evidence. Now~the A& of.Col3grefs (f x8.) exprefs.. ly fpecifies the firfc of thefe as one of the ibree thodes,~by ~hich the Circuit Cour.t thafi caufe the fa&s on which they found their Decree fully to appear. The qther modes of ftatin~ a c~ife by agreement of the parties, or, if they çiifagree, by an a& of the Court, are merely alternatives to be adopted when th~ other is iiieffe&ual; and as, in the pt-dent in{+ance, the plead- ings and Decree fully thew all the fa&s, on which the Court formed their judgn~ent, all that is fuperadded. is unneceffary and unauthorifed. Befide~, to~cate a cafe, and to furnith an ~bftra& of the evidence, are certainly things of a very distinct and distinguishable nature. In no case does the law require an abridge- nient or teltimony; anu in tots cale it is obvious mat me law reouires the faa to be hated, and not the evidei~ce of the. faa. Even, indeed, in the inffance of a fpecial verdi~,-if the )ut~r. ftate the evidence of the fa&, and do not find the fa& itfeif, the Court ~vi11 di(regard it ; and here, independent of the Decree,. rio fa~ is f~und, but merely an abf~ra~ of the evidence iscerti- fled by the Court. The faa effablilhed by th~ ~videnQe w~

Opinion of the Court — By the Court

Primary Opinion

By the Court

The decree ftates, that certain convey-

anees are fraudulent; and had it flopped with that general de-tdaration, fome doubt might reafonably b.e entertained, whether it was not more properly an inference, than the ftatement of a fait; fince fraud muft always principally depend upon the quo animo. But the court immediately afterwards proceed to deferibe the fraud, or quo animo, declaring, that “ the conveyances were intended to defraud the complainant, and to prevent his obtaining fadsfaition for a juft demandwhich is not an inference from a fait, bufa ftatement of the fail itfelf. It is another fail illuftrative of this pofition, that “ the grantee was a1 party and privy to the fraud.”

We are, therefore, of opinion, that the Circuit Court have fufficiently caufed the fails, on which they decided, to appear from the pleadings and decree, in conformity to the ait of Congrefs.

The decree affirmed.

Cited By Later Decisions (14)

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).