SCOTUS-Cases.net

Leland v. Wilkinson

31 U.S. 317 1832-01 2,137 Words
Full Case Caption
Thomas Leland and others v. David Wilkinson
Official & Parallel Citations
6 Pet. 317 · 31 U.S. 317 · 8 L. Ed. 412
Court & Volume
Supreme Court of the United States · 31 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

Thomas Leland and others v. David Wilkinson.

A paper certified by the secretary of state of Rhode Island, and by the governor, under the seal of the state, stating that certain laws were passed by t'ie legislature of that state, and thaf certain matters Were cognizable by the general assembly of Rhode Island, and of the practice of the assembly of Rhode Island in. cases of a particular description; is not evidence on the argument of a cause before this court. Usage and custom shotild be proved in the circuit court on the trial of the pase in which it may be referred to; and byidence of the same is not admissible in this court, if not found in the record'.

A certificate from the secretary of state of the state of Rhode Island, also Certified by the governor under the seal of the state, was offered to prove that certain proceedings have been had at different times in the legislature of Rhode Islaud on private petitions, relative to the administration and sale of (he-estates of deceased persons for the paymént of their debts; and that there have been certain usages and proceedings in’the legislature of that stale in.regard to the same. By the court: the public laws of a state may, without question, be read in this court,'and the exercise -of any authority which they contain may .be derived historically from them. -. But private laws, and special proceedings of this character, are governed by.a different rule. They are matters of fact, to be proved as such in the ordinary mannbr. This court cannot go into an inquiry as to the existence of such facts upon a writ, of .error, if they aré not found in the record. •

THIS case came before the court on a certificate of division in opinion of the judges of the circuit cou.rt of the United States for the district of Rhodé Island.

The. same cause was before the court on a writ of error at January term 1829. 2 Peters, 267. The case was again tried in the circuit court of Rhode Island at June term 1830; and the points on which the judges of that court were divided, were' ■certified to this court.

After the case had been argued by Mr Dutton for the plaintiff, with whom also was Mr Webster; Mr Whipple for the defendant, with whom also.was Mr Wirt, proposed toread^ as evidence of the. law of Rhode Island upon the probate of wills and granting of administration, and of. the other matters therein stated, the following certificate:

Opinion of the Court — Mr Chief Justice Marshall

Primary Opinion

The judges having severally expressed their opinion,

Mr Chief Justice Marshall

said, the evidence objected to is-' understood to be offered to prove that certain proceedings have been had at different, times in the legislature of Rhode Island, on private petitions of a similar nature with that before the court; and that there haye been certain usages and proceedings in the legislature of Rhode Island, in regard to th'e administration and sale of the estates of deceased persons for their debts, which will establish, that it has for a long period by usage, and rightfully, exercised the authority contended for by the defendant. The public laws of a state may without question be read in this court; and the exercise of any authority which they contain, may be deduced historically from them: but private laws, and special proceedings of the character spoken of, are governed by a different rule. They are matters of fact, to be -proved as such in the ordinary manner. This court cannot go into an inquiry as to the existence of such facts upon a writ of error, if they are not found on the record. The evidence, if not objected to, might have been heard; but since it is controverted, the matter of fact must be ascertained in the circuit court.

Mr Justice Baldwin dissented.

[Upon this decision, the parties consented to remand the cause to the circuit court for further inquiry into the facts.]

Cited By Later Decisions (4)

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).