Scott v. Ezra Lunt's Administrator
Syllabus & Case Posture
Richard M. Scott, Plaintiff in Error v. Ezra Lunt’s Administrator, Defendant in Error.
The plaintiff claimed in his declaration the sum of one thousand two hundred and forty-one dollars, and laid his damages at one thousand dollars:' ar general verdict having been given against him, the matter in dispute is the sum he claims, ad quod damnum. The court cannot judicially take notice, that.by computation it may possibly be. mads out as matter of inference from the plaintiff’s declaration, that the claim may be less than one thousand dollars; much less can it take such notice in a case where the plaintiff might be allowed interest by a jury, so-as tp swell the claim beyond one thousand dollars.
ERROR to the circuit' court of the United States for the county of Alexandria.
The plaintiff in error brought an action of covenant on a deed for certain premises in the city of Alexandria, by which the same were-granted to Ezra Lunt, the defendant’s intestate, reserving a yearly rent charge of seventy-three dollars. The declaration stated that the plaintiff became entitled to demand and have of the said Ezra, in his lifetime, and of the defendant after his death, the said annual rent of seventy-three dollars; “and the said plaintiff, in.fact saith, that after the.death of the said Ezra there became due and owing to him, from the defendant, as administrator aforesaid, for the rents aforesaid, from the 8th day of August 1812 to the 8th day of August 1824, the sum of twelve hundred and forty-one dollars, which said sum of twelve hundred and forty-one dollars the said defendant, since the death of the said Ezra Lunt, has altogether fáiled to pay to the said plaintiff; and so the said plaintiff saith, that the said defendant, as administrator aforesaid, hath broken the covenant aforesaid, whereby the said plaintiff hath been injured, and hath sustained damage to the value of one thousand dollars, and thereof he brings suit.”
The defendants pleaded a re-entry on the premises for nonpayment of the rent, by virtue' of the condition of re-entry-contained in the deed before the day specified, in the declaration for the'payment of the same; and that the plaintiff held and occupied the premises vested in him by the re-entry. Upon this plea issue was joined, and a verdict and judgment were rendered in favour of the defendant.
Bills of exceptions to the ruling of the court on matters of law were tendered by the plaintiff, and this writ of error was prosecuted by him.
Opinion of the Court — Mr Chief Justice Marshall
Primary OpinionMr Chief Justice Marshall
delivered the opinion of the Court.
Upon an inspection of the record, it appears that the plaintiff claims in his declaration the sum of twelve hundred and forty-one dollars as remaining due to him, and he has laid the ad damnum at one thousand dollars. Under such circumstances, a general verdict having been given against him, the matter in dispute is, in our opinion, the sum which he claims in the ad damnum. The court cannot judicially take notice, that by computation it may possibly be made oút as matter of inference from the declaration, that the plaintiff’s claim, in reality, must be less than one thousand dollars: much less can it take such notice in a case where tbe plaintiff might be allowed interest on his claim by the jury, so as to swell his claim beyond one thousand dollar’s. The motion to dismiss for want of jurisdiction is overruled.