Owings v. Kincannon
Syllabus & Case Posture
Thomas Deye Owings, and others, appellants v. Andrew Kincannon, appellee.
Appeal dismissed because all the parties to the decree in the circuit court had not joined in the appeal to this court.
APPEAL from the circuit court of the United States for the district of Kentucky.
In the circuit'court of Kentucky, Andrew Kincannon, the appellee, filed a bill on the 28 th of December 1815, claiming a tract of land, by virtue of a prior entry to that under which the persons named in the bill asserted a title to, and held possession of the land; and praying the court to compel the defendants to release all claim to the, same, and that he might be quieted in the enjoyment and possession thereof.
The bill was filed against Thomas Deye Owings,-James M. Blakey, Ralph Phillips, John Head, Benjamin Head, Milton Stapp, Charles Buck, and nineteen others, as defendants, and was afterwards dismissed as to some, and abated as to others of the persons so named. During the pendency of the proceedings Ralph Phillips and John Head died, the former leaving Lewis W. R.- Phillips his heir, and the other leaving Nancy Headj and his widow, Sally Head, his only child; who after the decease of their respective parents became defendants in the cause.
At November term, 1825, the circuit court: made a decree in favour of the complainant, by which it was ordered, that the complainant do recover against the defendants Thomas Deye Owings, James M. Blakey, .Ralph Phillips, Milton Stapp, John L. Head,' and Charles Brick, and that said defendants do, on or before the first day of March next, by deed, with warranty against themselves and their heirs, convey and release unto the complainant all their right, title, and interest, in and to the land represented on and designated on the connected plat, returned under an interlocutory decree formerly made.
Opinion of the Court — Mr Chief Justice Marshall
Primary OpinionMr Chief Justice Marshall
delivered the opinion of the court.
This is An appeal from a decree pronounced in the court of the United States for the district of Kentucky, by which Thomas Deye Owings,-James W. Blakey, Ralph Phillips, Milton Stapp, John L. Head and Charles Buck were directed to convey and release to the complainant all their right, title and interest in a tract of land mentioned in the decree. An appeal was allowed, and a bond executed by Lewis W. R. Phillips, Sally Head arid Nancy Head, the condition of which recites “ that, whereas Lewis W. R. Phillips,' Sally Head and Nancy Head have prayed for and have obtained an appeal from the seventh circuit court of the United States in and for the Kentucky district to the supreme court of the United States, in a certain suit in chancery wherein said Andrew Kincannon was complainant and Thomas D. Owings, Ralph Phillips, the Ancestor of the said L. W. R. Phillips, and John L. Head, the husband of said Sally Head and ancestor of Nancy Head, were defendants.
“ Now, if the said'Lewis W. R. Phillips shall well and truly prosecute,” &c.
The particular statement in the bond is considered by the court as explaining the general entry granting the appeal, so as to show that from a joint decree against six defendants, only two, represented by their heirs, have appealed.
A motion is now made to. dismiss this appeal, because the decree being joint, all the parties ought to join in the appeal.
Upon principle it would seem reasonable, that the whole cause ought to be brought before the court, and that all the parties who are united in-interest ought to unite in the appeal. We have however found no precedent, in chancery proceedings, for our government in this case. But in the case of Williams v. The Bank of the United States, 11 Wheat. 114, which was a writ of error, sued out by one defendant to a joint judgment against three, the writ was dismissed; the court being of opinion that it had issued irregularly* and that all the defendants ought to have joined in it.
By the judicial act of 1789, decrees in chancery pronounced in A circuit court could be brought before this court only by writ of error. The Appeal was given by the act of 1803. That act declares “that such appeals.shall be subject to the same rules, regulations and restrictions as aré prescribed by law. in cases of writs of error.”
Previous to the passage of this act, the decree under consideration could have been brought into this court only by writ of error, in which writ all the defendants must have joined. The language of the act which gives the appeal, appears to us to require that it should be prosecuted by the same parties Who would have been necessary in a writ of error.. We think also that the same principle would be applicable, from the general usage of chancery, to make one final decree binding on all the parties united in interest.
The appeal, must be dismissed, having been brought up irregularly.
On consideration of. the motion made in this cause on a prior day of the present term of this court, to wit, on Thursday the 17thday of January, by Mr Bibb, of counsel for the appellee, to dismiss this appeal, on the ground that only two of the parties, represented by their heirs, have joined in this appeal, the decree of the said circuit court being a joint decree against six persons, and of the arguments of counsel thereupon had: It is considered by the court that this appeal be dismissed, because only a part of those against whom the decree was made have joined in' the appeal. Whereupon, it is ordered, adjudged and decreed by this court that this appeal be, and the same is hereby dismissed, it having been brought up irregularly. ’ And it is further ordered, adjudged and decreed by this court that said appeal be, and the same is hereby dismissed with costs.