SCOTUS-Cases.net

Bradley v. Washington, Alexandria & Georgetown Steam Packet Co.

34 U.S. 107 1835-01 3,666 Words
Full Case Caption
William A. Bradley, plaintiff in error v. The Washington, Alexandria and Georgetown Steam Packet Company
Official & Parallel Citations
9 Pet. 107 · 34 U.S. 107 · 9 L. Ed. 68
Court & Volume
Supreme Court of the United States · 34 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

William A. Bradley, plaintiff in error v. The Washington, Alexandria and Georgetown Steam Packet Company.

■The original writ was issued out of the circuit court of the district of Columbia, dated 2d of December 1831, and was returned “ executed” on the first Monday of tho same December, the return day of the succeeding term. The defendant appeared by his attorney on the return day, and obtained a rule on the plaintiffs to declare against him. The circuit court, on the trial of the cause, directed the jury to find damages against the defendant, for the hire of a steamboat, for which the action was brought, from the 20th of November 1831 to the 6th, of February 1832, whereas the suit was instituted on the 2d of December 1831. These instructions were erroneous, as damages were to be given to a time long posterior to the institution of the action.

ERROR from the circuit court of the United States for the district of Columbia, in the county of Washington.

On the 2d of December 1831, a writ of capias ad respond-endum, in case, was sued out of the circuit court, by the Washington, Alexandria and Georgetown Steam Packet Company against William A. Bradley, the plaintiff in error, and on the return day of the writ, the first Monday in December 1831, the defendant appeared, and a rule on the plaintiffs to declare was entered, on the motion of his attorney. Further proceedings in the case were, by consent of the parties, continued until the fourth Monday in March 1833, when a declaration on in-debitatus assumpsit was filed; on which it was alleged that the defendant, William A. Bradley, was indebted to the plaintiffs on the 7th of February 1832, in the sum of 2765 dollars, for the use and hire of the steamboat Franklin. The defendant pleaded non assumpsit, and the case was tried in November 1833. The jury, under the directions of the court, gave a verdict for the plaintiffs for 2415 dollars, upon which judgment was entered, and the defendant prosecuted this writ of error. On the trial of the cause, the following bill of exceptions was tendered, and sealed by the court,

“Upon the trial of this cause the plaintiffs, to sustain the issue on their part, joined between the parties-aforesaid, gave in evidence, and read to the jury, a paper dated. 19th November 1831, signed by William A. Bradley, the said defendant, in the words and figures following, viz.

“ 1 agree to hire the steamboat Franklin, until the Sydney is placed on the route, to commence tomorrow, 20th instant, at thirty-five dollars per day, clear of all. expenses, other than the wages of Capt. Nevitt. 19th Nov., 1831.

Opinion of the Court — . Mr Chief Justice Marshall'

Primary Opinion

. Mr Chief Justice Marshall'

delivered the opinion’ of the Court.

This case depends on the correctness of an instruction given by the circuit court to the jury at the trial of. the cause, to which instruction the defendant in that court excepted.

The suit was instituted by the Washington, Alexandria and Georgetown Steamboat Company, for the hire of the steamboat Franklin, during the absence of the steamboat Sydney, the parties having disagreed with respect to the .time for which the contract was made. After the testimony was concluded, the court instructed the jury, that if they “shall believe, from the evidence aforesaid, that the said defendant did, on the 29th day of November 1831, write to the said plaintiff the said paper of that date, bearing his signature, and that the said plaintiff did accept the same by the said paper of the same date, and that the said defendant and plaintiff did respectively write to each other the papers bearing date the 5th and 6th of December 1831, and that the said steamboat Sydney did. in fact first arrive in the Potomac river, on the 6th of February 1832, and was placed on the route to Potomac creek, mentioned in the said evidence, on the 7th of February 1832, that then the said plaintiff is entitled to recover, under said contract so proved as aforesaid, at the .rate of 35 dollars per diem, from the said 20th of November 1S31, to the said 6th of February 1832, both inclusive;” The defendant, excepted to this instruction, and has sued forth a writ of error to the judgment, which was rendered on the verdict of the jury.

The original writ appears in the record, and bears date the 2d day of December 1831. It was returned executed on the first Monday in December, that being the first dap of the succeeding term, the day to which it was made returnable. The following entry was made on that day: “and the said .William A. Bradley, being called, appears in court here, by Joseph H. Bradley, his attorney, and thereupon th£> said, Wil-' liam A. Bradley, by his said attorney, prays, that the plaintiffs may declare against him, the said defendant, in the plea aforesaid ; whereupon it is ruled by the court here, that the said plaintiffs declare,” &c.

One objection taken by the plaintiff in error to the instruction given by the circuit court is, that they directed the jury to find damages for the'hire of the steamboat Franklin, from the 20th of November 183Í to the 6th of February 1832, whereas the suit was instituted on the 2d of December 1831.

The counsel for the defendant does not contend that the hire of the Franklin could be estimated or damages given to any time posterior to the institution of the suit, but he insists that the writ is only intended to bring the party into court, and unless spread on the record by pleading, is no part of it.

Without entering into this inquiry, it is- to be observed in the present case, that the defendant appeared in the circuit Gourt in December 1831, and gave' a rule to declare. These facts are entered on the record and must be noticed. This court, therefore, cannot fail to perceive that the jury was instructed to give damages to a time long posterior to the institution of the suit.

The judgment is reversed and the cause remanded, with directions to award a venire facias de novo.

This cause came on to be heard on the transcript of the record from the circuit court of the United States for the district of Columbia, holden in and for the county of Washington, and was argued by counsel; on consideration whereof, it is adjudged and ordered by this court, that the judgment of the said circuit court in this cause be, and the same is hereby reversed, and that this cause be, and the same is hereby remanded to the said circuit court, with directions to award a venire’ facias de novo.

Cited By Later Decisions (1)

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).