SCOTUS-Cases.net

Ex parte Milburn

34 U.S. 704 1835-01 2,692 Words
Full Case Caption
Ex parte George Milburn
Official & Parallel Citations
9 Pet. 704 · 34 U.S. 704 · 9 L. Ed. 280
Court & Volume
Supreme Court of the United States · 34 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

Ex parte George Milburn.

Habeas corpus. As the jurisdiction of the supreme court'is appellate, it must be shown to the court, that the court has the power to award a habeas corpus before one, will be granted. ,

George Milburn was imprisoned in the jail of the.county of washington, upon a bench warrant issued by the circuit court of the United States fpr the 'District of Columbia, to answer an indictment pending against him for keeping a faro bank, an offenpe which, by an act of congress, is punishable by imprisonment at hard labour in the penitentiary of the dis: trict. He had been arrested ón a former capias issued on the same indictment, upon which he gave a recognizance of bail, with sureties, in the sum of 100 pounds,-Maryland currency, according to the statute of Maryland, conditioned to appear in court at the return day of the process, &c. He did not appear, and the. recognizance was forfeited, and a scire facias was issued against him and his sureties, returnable to December term 1833. At the same term another writ of capias was issued against him, returnable immediately, and returned “non est inventus.” At June vacation 1834, another writ-of capias was issued against him, returnable to November term 1834, on which he was arrested, and from which arrest he was discharged on a habeas corpus by the chief justice of the circuit court, on the ground that the writ of capias improperly issued. On a return of this. discharge by the marshal, a bench warrant was issued by order of a majority of the judges of the circuit court, and on which he was in custody. He applied for a writ of habeas corpus to this court, to obtain his discharge. Held, that he ■ was- properly in custody. The rule for .the habeas corpus was • refused.

A RULE tó show cause why a habeas, corpus should not be awarded to bring up the body of George'' Milburn, in confinement in the jáil of the-county of Washington in the District of Columbia. ,

The case, as stated in the opinion of / the court, was as follows;

„ “ This is an application to the court by petition for a writ of habeas corpus to bring up the body> of George Milburn, now imprisoned in the jail of Washington county in the District of Columbia, upon a bench wafrant issued against him by .the circuit court of this district, to arrest him to answer to an in- ■ dictmeni now pending in,the same court against Him for keeping a faro bank, an offence which, by the act of congress of the 2d of March 1831, cb. 37, is punishable by imprisonment and. labour in the penitentiary of the • district. The main grounds for the application (for it is not necessary to go into the minute facts) are, that the party was. arrested on a former capias issued on the same indictment; upon which he gave a recognizance of bail with, sureties in the sum of 100 pounds 'Maryland currency, (266 dollars.67 cents) according to the statute of Maryland} passed in October T780, ch. 10 (which is in force in this district), conditioned to appear in court on.the returfi day of the process, to attend the court from day to day, and not to depart .therefrom without leave of' the court.' At the return day he did not' appear, and the 'recognizance was forfeited, and a scire facias issued against him and his sureties, returnable to November 1833. At the same ¿erro, another writ of capias on the indictment was issued against liim, returnable immediate, which was returned non est inventus. Af-terwards, in June 1834, in vacation, another writ of capias was issued by the district attorney upon the same indictment, returnable to November term 1834,.upon which the party was arrested, and from which, upon a writ of habeas corpus, he was discharged by Mr Chief Justice Cranch, of the circuit court, Upon the ground that- the writ of capias improperly issued. The marshal1 having returned this matter. specially to the circuit court, at the November term 1834; upon motion of the district attorney, the present, bench warrant was issued by order'of the majority of the court, and upon which the party is now in custody.”

Opinion of the Court — Mr Justice Story,

Primary Opinion

Mr Justice Story,

after stating the facts of the case, delivered the opinion cf the Court. .

The points principally relied on at the argument are, in the first place, that the party is not liable .to be arrested to answer the indictment, after having given a recognizance of bail; although the recognizance has been forfeited, and the party has not appeared and answered, and been tried on the indlament : in the next place, that the discharge upon the habeas corpus before Mr Chief Justice Cranch, is a bar to any subsequent arrest.

We are of opinion that neither of these grounds can, in point of law, be maintained; A recognizance of bail, in a criminal case, is taken to secure the due attendance of the party accused, to answer th.e indictment, and to submit to a trial, and the judgment of the court thereon; It is not designed as a satisfaction for the offence, when it is forfeited and paid; but as a means of compelling the party to submit to the trial and punishment, which the la\v ordains for his offence. And, a fortiori, it cannot be deemed to apply to a case like the present, of a penitentiary offence; for that would be to suppose that the law allowed the party to purge away the offence, and the corporeal punishment, by a pecuniary compensation. There is nothing, in our opinion, in the Maryland statute of 1780, ch. 10, to charge this construction of the law.

The other ground is also unmaintainable. A discharge of ■ a party under a writ of habeas corpus from the process under which he is imprisoned, discharges him from any further confinement under the process; but not under any other process, which may be issued against him under the same indictment.

For these reasons we are of opinion that the party is rightfully in custody under the bench warrant of the circuit court; and therefore, that the petition for the writ of habeas corpus ought to be denied.

The rule, therefore, to show cause is discharged; and the motion for the habeas corpqs is overruled.

Precedents Cited (1)

Cited By Later Decisions (5)

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).