SCOTUS-Cases.net

M'Bride v. Lessee of Hoey

36 U.S. 167 1837-01 2,540 Words
Full Case Caption
James M'Bride, plaintiff in error v. The Lessee of William Hoey
Official & Parallel Citations
11 Pet. 167 · 36 U.S. 167 · 9 L. Ed. 673
Court & Volume
Supreme Court of the United States · 36 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

James M'Bride, plaintiff in error v. The Lessee of William Hoey.

Jurisdiction. The Supreme Court has no power under the twent.y-fifth section of the judiciary act of 1789, to revise the decree of a state court, when no question . was raised or decided in the state court upon the validity or construction of an act of congress, nor upon the authority exercised under it, but on a state law only.

IN error to the Supreme Court of the western district of the state of Pennsylvania.

An action of ejectment was instituted by the lessee of William Hoey against James M‘Bride, the tenant of William Clarke, in the common pleas of Mercpr county, to recover a tract of land in that county. The plaintiff obtained a verdict; and judgment on the same was rendered by the court; and the case Was carried by writ'of error to the supreme court of the western district of Pennsylvania, where the judgment was affirmed.

To that court, as the highest court of law of the state, this writ of error was prosecuted, under the provisions of the twenty-fifth section of the judiciary act of September, 1789; the .plaintiff in error claim-, ing the exercise of the jurisdiction of this Court, on the allegation that an act of congress has been misconstrued by the supreme court of Pennsylvania.

The plaintiff in the ejectment, in the common pleas of Mercer county, exhibited a regular title derived under the laws of the state of Pennsylvania, subjecting unseated or unoccupied lands to sale for taxes left unpaid by the owner of the land. These laws give to the owners of such lands a right to redeem them within two years after the sale; by payment or tender, to the county treasurer, of the taxes for which the lands were sold, with twenty-five per-cent, in addition. In the courts of Pennsylvania, construing the laws of that state, it has been decided that no one but the owner of the land, or his agent can be permitted to redeem lands so sold.

Opinion of the Court — Mr. Chief Justice Taney

Primary Opinion

Mr. Chief Justice Taney

delivered the opinion of the Court.

This case comes before the Court on a writ of error, directed to the judges of the supreme court of Pennsylvania for the western district.

The material facts in the case may be stated in. a few words; William Hoey, the defendant in error, brought an action of ejectment in the court of common pleas of Mercer county, for the land in question; claiming under a deed from Aaron Hakney, treasurer of the county, upon a sale made for taxes due on the said land to the state of Pennsylvania. This deed is dated October 14, 1822. The defendant offered in evidence a deed to him from Theophilus T. Ware, collector of the United States direct taxes, for the 10th collection district of the state of Pennsylvania, dated July 3, 1821; and also offered evidence, that on the 10th of June, 1824, he had paid to the treasurer of the county the taxes due on the land to the state, and for which it had been sold, as above stated, in order to redeem it.

It appears from the exception, that the defendant admitted that the sale made by the United States collector, was not warranted by the act of congress, and that the deed was invalid. But although the deed was inoperative, and did not convey the title to him, yet as he was in possessiomunder this deed, claiming title, and the deed upon the face of it purported to convey the land to him; he insisted that the deed, coupled with the possession under it, ’ivas sufficient evidence of title to authorize him to redeem the Jand, within the time United for redemption by the laws of’ Pennsylvania, after a sale for state taxes; and that-having paid the taxes within that time, the title of the lessor under his deed was defeated.

The court of common pleas gave judgment in favour of the plaintiff; and the case being removed by writ of error to’ the supreme court of Pennsylvania for the western district, the judgment of the court of common pleas was there affirmed.

The statement of the case shows, that the question upon which the case turned, and which was decided by the supreme court, depended entirely upon the laws of Pennsylvania; and not upon the act'of congress. The question brought before the state,court, and there decided against the plaintiff in error, was this. Is a person in possession of land in Pennsylvania, claiming title to it, under a deed, which upon the face of it appears to be a'.good one, but which is inoperative .and invalid, entitled to redeem the land after it has been sold for taxes due to the state; so as to defeat the title of the purchaser under the state law? It is evident that such a question must depend altogether upon the laws, of the state, and not upon any'law of the United States. The exception states that the plaintiff in error admitted that the sale and conveyance made by the United States collector was not warranted by the act of congress, and that his deed was invalid. No question was raised or decided by the court, upon the validity or construction of the act of congress, nor upon the authority exercised under it. The only question raised or decided in the state court was the one above stated; and upon such a question, depending altogether upon the state laws, this Court have no power to revise the decision of the state court, in this fprm of proceeding. The writ of error must therefore be dismissed.'

On consideration of the motion made in this cause, yesterday, and of the arguments of counsel thereupon had, as well in support of, as against the motion; it is now here considered, ordered and.adjudged by this Court, that this writ of error to the supreme court of Pennsylvania for the western district be, and the same is hereby dismissed for the want of jurisdiction.

Precedents Cited (3)

Cited By Later Decisions (2)

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).