Ex parte Whitney
Syllabus & Case Posture
Ex parte Myra Clarke Whitney.
The district judge of the eastern district of Louisiana, while holding a Circuit Court, ordered proceedings on a bilMn equity to be in conformity with the rules of the Courts of . Louisiana, thus disregarding the rules for .proceedings in the Circuit Courts of the United States in cases in Chancery, prescribed, and ordered by the Supreme Court of the-United States. It was also declared that the practice and proceedings in all civil causes, those of admiralty alone excepted, should be conformable to the provisions of the Code of Practice of Louisiana, and of the acts of the legislature of the state. -Under this order, aird by the course of the Court, the proceedings .on the bill in equity were suspended and prevented. A motion was made for a mandamus to the Circuit Court, in the nature of a writ of procedendo, to compel the Court to proceed in the cause according to the rules of practice prescribed to the Courts of equity of the United- States, &c., to award attachments; &c., and in all things to proceed in the cause in such manner as the Constitution and laws of the United States, and the principles and usages in equity will authorize. Held, that this is not a 'case in-which a mandamus will lie.- The appropriate redress, if any, is to be obtained after the final-decision shall be had on the cause, by appeal.
A writ of mandamus is not the appropriate remedy for any errors which may be made in a cause; by a judge in the exercise of his authority; although they may seem to bear harshly or oppressively on the party. The remedy in such cases must be' sought in somé other form.
MR. JONES presented a petition, and moved the Court for á mandamus in the nature of it writ of-procedendo, to be directed, to the Circuit Court of the United States, for the eastern district of Louisiana.
Mr. Jones, for petitioner, stated, that William W-. Whitney, and Myra Clarke Whitney, had filed a bill in the District Court of the United States for the" eastern district of Louisiana, which was after-wards transferred to the Circuit Court.' The complainant, William W. Whitney, having died pendente lite, the suit was continued in the name of his widow, Myra Clarke Whitney;
The subpoena issued on the bill was served on a number of defendants, and among them on Relf and Chew. The object of the bill is to recover property devised to the complainant by a will of Daniel Clarke, in which the complainant, his only child, and heii-at law, was his general legatee;'and Relf and Chew are charged in the bill with having fraudulently concealéd and suppressed this will, and havirig set up a prior and revoked will, in which they are named executors, with plenary powers of disposal and sale over the real estate of the testator; and they had-disposed of the immense estate; under colour of their oifice and authority, as executors and testamentary legatees; whilst the complainant for a time, an infant of tender years, was in ignorance of her parentage and true name, and.of his rights. • The other defendants, are charged with combining with Chew .and Rélf; and with having purchased, and withholding- parts of the estate of Daniel Clarké, under sales by Chew and Relf..
Opinion of the Court — Mr. Justice .Stoky
Primary OpinionMr. Justice .Stoky
delivered the Opinion of the Court.
This is the case of a motion made on behalf of Myra C^rke Whitney, for a mandamus to the Circuit .Court, of the eastern district of J_,ouisiana. The petition on which the motion is founded states that a bill in equity is now -pending in the said Circuit Court, in'which the petitioner is plaintiff, against Richard Relf and Others, defendantsthat it is understood to be the settled determination of .the district judge'-not to suffer chancery practice to -prevail in the Circuit Court; that her right to proceed in her suit has been denied, until she shall-cause copies of her bill in the French language to be served upon the defendants or-some of them, and-until she shall file documents, which are not made exhibits in the cause; and then that all further proceedings in the cause shail be in conformity with the existing practice of the Court, which existing practice is understood to mean the practice prevailing in the Court in civil cases generally, in disregard of the rules established by the Supreme Court to be observed in chancery cases. The prayer of the petition is for a rriandamus in; the nature of a writ of procedendo, to compel the Court to proceed according to-chancery practice, to award an attachment, and compel Relf to answer her bill, and to suffer the petitioner in all things to proceed in the - cause ip such manner as.the constitution and laws .of the United States, arid the principles and'usages in equity will authorize. A copy of the bill, and the orders and proceedings of the district judge -thereon, are presented with the petition.
That it is the duty of-the. Circuit Count to proceed in this suit according to the rules prescribed by the Supreme Court for proceedings in equity causes at the February term thereof, a. d.- 1822, can admit of no doubt. That the proceedings of the district judge, and the orders made by. him in the cause, which are complained of, "are not in-conformity with those rules, and with chancery practice, -can admit of as little doubt.' But the -question before us is not as to the regularity and propriety of those proceedings, but whether the case before us is one in which a mandamus ought to issue. And We are of opinion that it is not such a case. The - district judge is proceeding in the cause,- however irregular that proceeding may be deemed; and the appropriate redress, if any, is to be obtained by an appeal after the final decree shall be had in the cause. A writ of mandamus is not the appropriate remedy for any orders which may be made in a cause by a judge in the exercise of his authority, although they may séem to, bear harshly or oppressively upon the party. The remedy in such eases must be sought in some other form.
The' motion for the mandamus is therefore denied.
On petition for a mandamjis or for a-rule to show cause why such writ should .not issue requiring the judges of the ninth judicial circuit to proceed in this cause, according to the rules of equity. On consideration of the motion made in this, cause by Mr. Jones, on a prior day of the present term of this Court, to wit, on Saturday, the 26th day of January last, and of the argument of counsel thereupon. had, it is nowhere ordered, adjudged, and decreed by this Court, that the said motion be and the same is hereby overruled.