Lupton v. Janney
Syllabus & Case Posture
Ann Lupton, Appellant, vs. Phineas Janney, Executor of David Lupton, the younger, deceased, Appellee.
The executor of 1. filed.- his. accounts in. thé Orphans Court of .Alexandria, in 1818 and 1818, and' settled his final, amount in 1821. No exceptions .were taken to the accounts. In November, 1831, a subpoena, wás issued against the executor, -and in June,. 1833, a bill was filed by the devisee and legatee against the executor, the object of which . was to surcharge and falsify the accounts filed and settled in the Ofphans Court. The bill did.not charge the executor with fraud; but imputed negligence, which was alleged to amount to a devastavit No' reason was given or facts stated to excuse the long delay and laches in bringing the bill. Held,- that the lapse of time from the settlement of the accounts of the executor was a bar to this proceeding.
Nothing is more clear than, tire general 'rulé, that ex parte settlements of accounts by exe« cutors in the Orphans Court, being matters within'the acknowledged jurisdiction of the Court in the administration of estates, are prima facie evidence of their correctness, and. • the onus probandi is upon .those who seek to impeach, them. If they seek- to impeach them, it should tie by a suit brought, recenti facto, within a' reasonable time, arid, at farthest within the period prescribed ,by the' statute of limitations for actions at lawpn maters of account; -or' else assign some ground of exception or disability-within the analogy of the statute, to justify^ or 'excuse the delay. ' Otherwise it will be' imputed to their voluntary laches,'.and relief will not be given by á Court o.f equity.
ON appeal from the Circuit Court of the United States, for the county of Alexandria, in the district of Coluinhia.
A hill was filed on-a subpoena, which had issued from the.Circuit Court on the fifth day of November, 1831; by Ann Lupton, thé splé devisee and legatee of David Lupton the younger,:for the purpose of surcharging and falsifying the accounts of the executor, Phineas -Janney, which had been settled, in thrée accounts rendered by him to and aÚo ed by the Orphans. Court of Alexandria.. The first account .was rendered-and was settled on the 26th of October, 1816. The second account was settled on the. 16th of April, 1818, and on the 5th of January, 1821, ihe-executór renderéd and settled his final account. The bill of the complainant was filed on the 4th day of June, 1833. '
The complainant' alleged that the executor was chargeable with certain debts due to the estate of the testator,.which he had failed to collect, and for goods of the estate sold by him, the amount .of which sales had not been paid to him. Certain credits had been given in the accounts of the executor to .parties not entitled to them; and, in an amended bill, facts are charged which amounted to a devastavit, which it was alleged were not; satisfactorily contradicted by an amended answer. There was no imputation or' charge of fraud in the executor; but it was asserted, that gross negligence was to he imputed to the executor, for which he was answerable de bonis propriis.
Opinion of the Court — Mr. Justice Story
Primary OpinionMr. Justice Story
delivered the opinion of the Court.
This is a case of an appeal from a decree of the Circuit Court of the county of Alexandria, dismissing a bill in equity brought by the appellant, Ann Lupton, the widow and devisee of the testator, David Lupton. The bill was first filed in June, 1833, although a subpoena was issued in November, 1831, and' it seeks to open the accounts of the administration, upon the allegation of certain errors' and omissions therein, as they were settled in three successive accounts of the executor, rendered ex parte, and allowed in thé Orphans Court of Alexandria, in October,-1816, in April, '1818, and in January, 1821. The bill charges, among other things, that the estate was charged by the executor with the payment of a supposed debt of $4459 43, to one Peter Saunders, without any sufficient or legal evidence that it was in fact due. It also charges that the executor omitted to collect of John M‘Pherson and. Son a debt due to the ‘ estate of $4083 50, upon their note; and .also specifies certain credits which have been omitted to be given by the executor; and contains a general allegation that other debts have been lost to the estate by. the negligence of the executor.- The prayer of the bill is in effect to open the accounts, with general liberty to , surcharge and falsify. There is no charge in the bill that the executor has been guilty of any fraud; nor any reason given, nor facts stated, to excuse the long delay and laches in bringing the bill. The answer denies all equity, and. insists upon the correctness of the accounts as settled, and contains a full explanation, in reply to the specific charges of the bill. It also relies on the settlement of the accounts in the Orphans Court; and the lapse of time, as a bar- to the suit.
'{’he opinion which wé have formed upon this last point, renders it wholly unnecessary for us to consider several others- which have been discussed at the bar; and especially the objection, that the Orphans Court has exclusive jurisdiction Over the matters in controversy. Wé place this case Avholly upon the .ground of the lapse of time since the accounts were settled in the Orphans Court, a period, from twelve to.sixteen'years before the filing.of the bill; the total omission of the bill to state any facts, or circumstances to account for or excuse this long delay; and the absence of any suggestion of fraud in the settlements. Nothing is more clear than the general rule that ex; parte settlements of .accounts-of this sort, in the Orphans Court, being matters Avithin the acknowledged jurisdiction of the Court in the administration of estates, are prima facie evidence of their own verity and .correctness; and the onus probandi is upon those who seek to impeach them. If they seék to impeach them, it should be by a suit brought recenti-faeto, within a reasonable time; and at farthest; within the period prescribed by the statute of' limitations for.actions at law upon matters of account; or else to assign some ground of exception- or disability, within the analogy of the statute, to justify or excuse the delay. Otherwise it will be imputed to their own voluntary laches; and Courts of equity are never active in lending their aid to stale and neglected claims, for the known maxim of such Courts is, vigilantibus., non dormientibus leges subveniunt. We .do not deem it necessary to refer to any authorities on - this point, as it has been so long and so fully recognised in this Court; and upon this short ground, we are'all. of opinion that the decree of the Circuit Court dismissing the bill ought to be affirmed, with costs.
Thjs cause came on to be heard on the transcript of the record from the Circuit Court of the United States for the District of Columbia, holden in and for the county of Alexandria, and was argued by counsel. On consideration whereof, it is ordered and decreed by this Court, that the decree of the said Circuit Court in this cause be, and the same is hereby, affirmed, with costs.