Austyn v. McLure
Syllabus & Case Posture
*SEPTEMBER TERM, 1801.
Austyn v. McLure.
Consideration.
The smallest spark of benefit or accommodation is sufficient, to create a valid consideration for a promise.
Case, on a special assumpsit. The declaration contained three counts, of each of which, the following is the substance.
1st Count. — After stating that a controversy subsisted between the plaintiff and one Rowson (a British merchant, for whom the defendant was agent); that they had agreed to enter an amicable action and reference, in the federal circuit court, and that the referees met on the 12th of January 1798 ; the declaration proceeded, that at the said meeting, “ it was agreed between McLure and Austyn, that in consideration that the said Austyn would waive all objections to the referees proceeding to arbitrate between the said Rowsod and Austyn, and would submit the matters in controversy between them to the said referees; as' also in consideration of the said Austyn’s having promised, on demand thereof made, to give security to pay to the said McLure whatever sum the said referees might award to be paid to the said Rowson, should the said referees decide the said controversy and dispute against the said Austyn, he the said McLure undertook, &e., that he would well and truly pay the said Austyn whatever sum of money the said referees might award to be due from the said Rowson to the said Austyn.” And the declaration then averred, “ that Austyn did waive all objections, &c., and always was ready to give to the said McLure the said security above mentioned, when he should be required by the said McLure. And that the referees awarded a balance of $1454.06 to be due from Rowson to Austyn, &c.”
Opinion of the Court
Primary OpinionThe Court delivered a charge to the jury, in which they stated, that the smallest spark of benefit or accommodation, was sufficient to create a valid consideration for a promise ; and intimated, that their opinion was decidedly in favor of the plaintiff.
Verdict, accordingly, for the plaintiff.
Bbackenbidge, Justice, seemed to dissent from the opinion of the court, with this remark: “ The English books say, that there must be a spark of consideration (though a single spark is enough) to maintain an action upon a promise: but in this case, the court have blown out the spark; and I cannot perceive, whence they get light sufficient tc enable them to decide for the plaintiff.”