SCOTUS-Cases.net

Evans v. Bollen

4 U.S. 296 1800-04 984 Words
Full Case Caption
Evans, qui tam, &c., v. Bollen
Official & Parallel Citations
4 Dall. 296 · 4 U.S. 296
Court & Volume
United States Circuit Court for the District of Pennsylvania · 4 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

Evans, qui tam, &c., v. Bollen.

Jurisdiction. — Penal action.

The circuit court i annot take original cognisance of a suit for a penalty incurred by an offence against the laws of the United States: if the offence was committed within a state, it must be tried in such state. -

This was qui tam action, in which the following declaration was filed:

October Session, 1797.

In the Circuit Court of the United States for the Pennsylvania District, of the Middle Circuit.

Opinion of the Court

Primary Opinion

*The facts were proved, as stated in the declaration, but the de- pi:g44 fendants counsel made two objections to the jurisdiction of the court: *- 1st. That this was a suit under the second section, and the circuit court could not take original cognisance of a case of penalty or forfeitnre, as the judicial act expressly declared, that the district court should have “ exclusive original cognisance of all suits for forfeitures and. penalties incurred under the laws of the United States.” (1 U. S. Stat. 76, § 9.) 2d. That the offence was committed in the state of New York ; and ought to be tried there, upon the principles of the common law, adopted by the constitution of the United States, and various acts of congress. Const. Art. III., § 2 ; Amend. Const. Art. VIII, IX.; 4 Black. Com. 350; 3 Ibid. 359, 360; 2 Dall. 335.

It was agreed, that a verdict should be given for the plaintiff, subject to the opinion of the court on these points ; and after argument, by E. Tilghman, for the plaintiff, and Levy, for the defendant—

The Couet declared, that they had no jurisdiction of the cause; and directed a non-pros, to be entered.

The Cassius, 2 Dall. 365; Hall v. Warren, 2 McLean 382.

Precedents Cited (2)

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).