SCOTUS-Cases.net

Ewing v. Houston

4 U.S. 58 1799-07 2,187 Words
Full Case Caption
Ewing and wife, Plaintiffs in error, v. Houston and wife
Official & Parallel Citations
4 Dall. 58 · 4 U.S. 58
Court & Volume
Pennsylvania High Court of Errors and Appeals · 4 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

*JULY SESSIONS, 1799.

Before Rush, Ridlue, Addison, Henry and Coxe, Presidents of tbe Common Pleas.

Ewing and wife, Plaintiffs in error, v. Houston and wife.

Partition.— Variance.

A summons in partition, described tbe property to be divided, as follows: . “ One ferry at the river Susquehanna, in Hellam township, &c., six messuages, &e., with the appurtenances, in the same township of Hellam, in, &c.the writ of partition, in the recital of the summons, had these words: “with the appurtenances, in the same township of Hellam and Windsor, in, Ac.and in the specification of the property, the ferry was omitted, though it was named in another part of the writ: the inquisition enumerated among the premises which were divided, the “ ferry, and also a fishery on the river Susquehanna, at or near the said ferry, &e.Held, that these variances were not fatal.

It did not appear, by the return of the writ of partition, that the parties attended, or were warned to attend at its execution, and the inquisition did not state, that the property was assigned and delivered, but merely, that it was allotted: Held, that the partition was valid.

Opinion of the Court

Primary Opinion

On the last day of the session, the court mentioned, that some doubts had arisen, which would prevent a decision of the cause until the adjourned session ; but that, in the meantime, for their own information, they should direct a certiorari to issue to the court of common pleas of York county, to inquire whether any precept had been given, authorizing the writ of execution, or judicial writ of partition, to issue ; and if so, to return it.

Cur. adv. vult.

At an adjourned session, held on the 17th of January 1800, the court unanimously affirmed the judgment of the supreme court.

Judgment affirmed.

Lewis suggested a doubt, whether a certiorari could issue per saltern, to the common pleas, overleaping the supreme court, on whose judgment the writ of error was brought; but he agreed to give effect to any mode that might be taken to ascertain the fact in question, and to consider any precept that issued, as regularly annexed to the record.

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).