SCOTUS-Cases.net

Mayor of Philadelphia v. Mason

4 U.S. 230 1803-03 524 Words
Full Case Caption
The Mayor, &c., of Philadelphia v. Mason
Official & Parallel Citations
4 Dall. 230 · 4 U.S. 230
Court & Volume
Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · 4 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

*MARCH TERM, 1803.

The Mayor, &c., of Philadelphia v. Mason.

Penal action.

The return to a certiorari to remove the proceedings before the Mayor of Philadelphia, under an ordinance against huckstering, did not state a conviction, the offence, nor the place where the business was conducted: Held, that it was error.

This was a certiorari to remove the proceedings from the mayor into this court; to which he made the following return under seal:

The Mayor, Aldermen and Citizens ) November 19, 1800. v. >• Huckstering. Elizabeth Mason. ) Amicable action.

Opinion of the Court — By the Court.

Primary Opinion

By the Court.

— Some of the objections are insurmountable. In the first place, it is not sufficient to state the evidence ; but the magistrate must go on to declare, that the offence was committed, and the defendant thereof convicted. Here, neither the offence, nor the conviction, are to be found in the proceedings. In the next place, we have no statement where the defendant carried on the business of huckster ; and it might be, where it was no offence to do so ; or where the corporation had no jurisdiction to punish it as an offence. The proceedings are, therefore, manifestly erroneous, and must be set aside.

s. p. Philadelphia v. Nell, 3 Yeates 475; Commonwealth v. Gillingham, 1 Brews. 396; Philadelphia v. Mintzer, 2 Phila. 43; Philadelphia v. Roney, Id. 43.

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).