McFadden v. Parker
Syllabus & Case Posture
McFadden v. Parker et al.
Disoha/rge of indorser.
If the indorsee of a note, after obtaining judgment against the maker, should discharge him from custody under a ca. sa. issued by virtue of the judgment, the debt will be extinguished and the indorser released.
This was an action brought against Parker & Wharton, the indorsers of a promissory note, instituted at the same time that an action was brought against George Eddie, the maker of the note. There had been a trial, and verdict for the plaintiff, in December term 1801, subject to the opinion of the court upon a case stated, involving two questions : 1st. Whether a plea puis darrein continuance had not been entered too late by the defendants ? And 2d. Whether the new matter pleaded, was sufficient to bar the plaintiff’s recovery ? After some argument on the case, at December term 1802, the parties made the following arrangement:
“That the judgment shall remain as a security, and an issue be formed and tried under this agreement. That the defendants be permitted to enter, at this time, a plea puis darrein continuance, with like effect, as if it had been entered at the day given for their next appearance, after the new matter occurred. That the plaintiff be allowed to give evidence of all facts and circumstances to show that the new matter pleaded ought not to operate as a discharge of the defendants. That the defendants be allowed to give evidence of all facts and circumstances to repel such evidence on the part of the plaintiff to show that such new matter ought to operate in their discharge ; and to establish that the plaintiff has received actual value, or security, for the debt, from the maker of the note. And that it be admitted, on the trial, that notice, in due form of law, was given to the defendants, by the plaintiff, of the non-payment of the note, on which the suit is founded.”
Under this agreement, the defendants relinquished all former pleas, and entered puis darrein continuance, the plea of payment, with leave to give the special matter in evidence.
Opinion of the Court — By the Court.
Primary OpinionBy the Court.
— The case has been well argued at the bar; and the judges have enjoyed an opportunity to consider it, with more deliberation, than could be bestowed upon it, during the trial. We are now convinced, that the principal point of law should have been differently presented to the jury. It is clearly in favor of the defendants ; and ought to have been so stated in the charge.
The construction of the agreement, however, is a distinct subject for consideration. The counsel who drew the agreement, are essentially at variance upon its design and meaning; and the court have not formed (nor is it necessary, at this time, that we should form) a decided opinion upon the subject. The intention of the parties to the instrument, will be properly left to the jury, on the new trial; which, for the reason already assigned, it is our duty to award.
New trial awarded.