SCOTUS-Cases.net

O'Hara v. Hall

4 U.S. 294 1800-04 438 Words
Full Case Caption
O'Hara v. Hall
Official & Parallel Citations
4 Dall. 294 · 4 U.S. 294
Court & Volume
United States Circuit Court for the District of Pennsylvania · 4 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

*APRIL TERM, 1800.

Present — Chase, Justice, and Peters, District Judge.

O’Hara v. Hall.

Pwi'ol evidence.

Parol evidence is admissible to explain, but not to alter, a written contract.

In an action by the assignee of a bond, against the assignor, upon a written assignment, in genera! terms, parol testimony is not admissible, to show that the defendant had expressly guarantied the payment.

Opinion of the Court — Chase, Justice. Peters, Justice.

Primary Opinion

Chase, Justice.

— You may explain, but you cannot alter, a written contract, by parol testimony. A case of explanation implies uncertainty, ambiguity and doubt, upon the face of the writing. But the proposition now, is a plain case of alteration: that is, an offer to prove by witnesses, that the assignor promised something, beyond the plain words and meaning of his written contract. Such evidence is inadmissible; and has been so adjudged by the supreme court, in Clarke v. Russell, 3 Dall. 415. As to the authority of Moses v. Macferlan, it has always been suspected, and has lately been overruled, on the principle, *that the previous decision, there brought into question, was pronounced by a competent court. I grant, that chancery will not confine itself to the strict rule, in cases of fraud and of trust. But we are sitting as judges at common law; and I can perceive no reason to depart from it.

Peters, Justice.

— If we were sitting as judges in a state court, I should be inclined to admit the testimony, in order to attain the real justice of the cause ; as there is no court of equity in Pennsylvania. But there is no such defect in the federal jurisdiction ; and therefore, when the party comes to the common-law side of the court, he must be content with the strict common-law rule of evidence.

Precedents Cited (2)

Cited By Later Decisions (1)

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).