SCOTUS-Cases.net

Penn v. Butler

4 U.S. 308 1801-05 1,356 Words
Full Case Caption
Penn v. Butler; Butler v. Penn; Penn v. Penn; Same v. Same
Official & Parallel Citations
4 Dall. 308 · 4 U.S. 308
Court & Volume
United States Circuit Court for the District of Pennsylvania · 4 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

Penn v. Butler. Butler v. Penn. Penn v. Penn. Same v. Same.

Possession of securities.

The survivor of two joint obligees, is, at law, entitled to the possession of the joint securities; and a court of equity will not interfere with the disposition of them, unless some ground is laid for its interposition.

These were bills in equity, involving a great variety of facts, respecting the disposition of the estates of the late proprietary family : but the principal object of all of them, was submitted for the opinion of the court, on the following agreement :

“ It is agreed, that these suits be submitted for the opinion of the court upon the following statement of facts, admitted by :!:all the parties, -* except the fact, that Anthony Butler, for his own accommodation, and without the consent, knowledge or approbation of John Penn, the elder, took, inter alia, in part payment of certain sales hereinafter mentioned, certain bonds and mortgages, in the joint names of John Penn, the elder, and John Penn, the younger, as obligees and mortgagees ; which fact, it is agreed, shall be decided by the court, on evidence to be produced; and that such formal decrees be eventually drawn and entered in each, as will effectuate the opinion which the court shall pronounce.

Case. John Penn, the elder, and John Penn, the younger, after the act of assembly of Pennsylvania, passed November 27th, 1779, entitled “ an act for vesting the estates of the late proprietaries of Pennsylvania in this commonwealth,” remained seised and possessed, as tenants in common, of all their manors, reserved tracts, &c., in Pennsylvania, with power to sell in fee : three-fourth parts being the property of John Penn, the younger ; and one-fourth part being the property of John Penn, the elder. On the 19th of November 1787, John Penn, the elder, appointed John F. Mifflin his attorney, with power to sell and convoy, &c., to receive payment for lands sold, either in money or securities ; and to substitute any agent or agents ; and on the 23d of December 1787, John F. Mifflin substituted Anthony Butler. On the 29th day of June, in the year 1787, John Penn, the younger, appointed Robert Millegan and John F. Mifflin his attorneys, with power to sell and convey, &c., to receive payment for lands sold, either in money or securities ; and to substitute any agent or agents. And on the 29th day of June, in the year 1787, Robert Millegan and John F. Mifflin substituted Anthony Butler. John Penn, the younger, afterwards revoked the power of attorney, which he had granted to Robert Millegan and John F. Mifflin ; and on the 29th of April 1788, John Penn, the younger, appointed the said Anthony Butler his attorney, with power to sell and convey, and to receive in payment money or securities.

Opinion of the Court

Primary Opinion

The Court were decidedly of opinion, that, at law, tbe surviving obligee was entitled to tbe possession of tbe joint securities, that be might recover the amount; and that there was no ground laid, on tbe present occasion, for tbe interposition of a court of equity.

On this clear intimation of the opinion of the court, Mr. Coates liberally declared, that if the executors of John Penn, the elder, would concur in giving him immediate possession of the securities, he would not charge a commission for collecting and paying their proportion of the amount; and the proposition was, accordingly, agreed to

Precedents Cited (2)

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).