SCOTUS-Cases.net

Snell v. Delaware Insurance

4 U.S. 370 1806-10 876 Words
Full Case Caption
Snell et al. v. Delaware Insurance Company
Official & Parallel Citations
4 Dall. 370 · 4 U.S. 370
Court & Volume
United States Circuit Court for the District of Pennsylvania · 4 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

Snell et al. v. Delaware Insurance Company.

Measwre of damages. — Evidence of vaJ/ue.

On an open policy of insurance, the assured is entitled to recover according to the actual value of the vessel, at the time she was insured, and not according to her prime cost.

Evidence of prime cost is admissible, to show her real value, but it is not conclusive against the assured.

Covenant, on an open policy for $2500, at a premium of ten per cent., upon the brig Hound, on a voyage from Jamaica to New York.-

The facts were these : the brig and cargo, belonging to the plaintiffs, sailed on a voyage from New York to Curajoa, and back again ; but, upon the return voyage, she was captured by a British cruiser, and carried into Jamaica, where vessel and cargo wore libelled and condemned, on the 31st of July 1804, for a breach of blockade. The master, conceiving that the vessel would be sold, under her value, requested MessrsfCampbell & O’Hara, of Kingston, to buy her in for the owners, which was accordingly done, at the price of 1020?., equal to about $3500. For the price of the vessel, amount of repairs, outfits, &c. (in the whole 1939?. 4s. 11c?.), advanced by Campbell & O’Hara, those gentlemen took from the master an hypothecation of the vessel, to guaranty the payment of a bill of exchange, which he drew upon the owners: and on the 9th of August 1804, they requested Messrs. Savage & Dugan to procure insurance upon the vessel for $5000 ; which was effected at the office of the Phoenix Insurance Company, upon the following instructions :

Opinion of the Court

Primary Opinion

The Court were clearly of opinion, that the plaintiffs were entitled to prove and to recover the actual value of the vessel, at the time she was insured. They said, a contrary rule would operate as injuriously to the underwriters, as to the merchant. For, if the merchant could not insure a ship or goods, bought at a depreciated ‘•'price, under a forced sale, at their real value ; neither would the underwriter, in a case of *- loss, be entitled to show, upon an open policy, the actual value of the property, independent of a fortuitous enhancement of the price in -a foreign market.

The jury found a verdict for the plaintiffs, for $2378.32, taking, it is presumed, the value in the outward policy as the basis of their calculation.

“ As to the rule of ascertaining the value of a ship, it is agreed on all hands, that the sum she was worth, at the time of her departure, including certain expenses, is to govern, and the court can perceive no reason for establishing this rule, which does not apply to tne case of goods:” per Washington, J., Carson v. Marine Ins. Co., 2 W. C. C. 472.

Cited By Later Decisions (2)

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).