SCOTUS-Cases.net

Welsh v. Murray

4 U.S. 277 1805-03 739 Words
Full Case Caption
Welsh v. Murray
Official & Parallel Citations
4 Dall. 277 · 4 U.S. 277
Court & Volume
Supreme Court of Pennsylvania · 4 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

*MARCH TERM, 1805.

Welsh v. Murray.

Relation of judgment.

As between creditors, judgments do not relate to tbe preceding term, but they take priority according to the times of their entry.

Case stated for the opinion of the court. On the 1st of August 1804, judgment was entered, by confession, at the suit of Ewing v. Murray, in the common pleas of Philadelphia county ; in which the declaration was entitled of June term preceding. On the 3d of August 1804, judgment was entered, by confession, in the supreme court, against the same defendant, at the suit of Welsh, the present plaintiff; and the declaration was entitled as of March term preceding.

The question submitted was, which judgment was entitled to a priority of payment, from the proceeds of the sale of the defendant’s real estate ?

Opinion of the Court — By the Court.

Primary Opinion

By the Court.

— We are clearly of opinion, that the judgment first entered, is entitled to be first paid. The plaintiff in the common pleas must, therefore, enjoy his preference.

A question of priority of judgments also arose in the common pleas of Philadelphia county, at June term 1806, in the case of Emerick b. Garwood.

It was on a case stated between two creditors of the defendant, each of whom had entered judgment, by virtue of a bond and warrant, on the same day, at the distance of a few hours. It was held by the Court (Rush, President), that there should be no precedence between the judgments; but that the proceeds of the sales which arose from real estate, should be divided.

The reason chiefly assigned by the President, was the inconvenience of a contrary rule, there being several courts, in which judgment might be entered on the same day; and the authority on which he chiefly relied was Lord Porohester’s case, as stated by Buller, in IT. R. 118.

Milnor, for the second creditor. Rawle, contra.

s. c. 1 Bro. 20; s. p. Steele v. Taggert, Id. 20 n.; Mitzler v. Kilgore, 3 P. & W. 245.

Precedents Cited (2)

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).