SCOTUS-Cases.net

Ex parte Crenshaw

40 U.S. 119 1841-01 2,183 Words
Full Case Caption
Ex parte Anderson Crenshaw
Official & Parallel Citations
15 Pet. 119 · 40 U.S. 119 · 10 L. Ed. 682
Court & Volume
Supreme Court of the United States · 40 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

Ex parte Anderson Crenshaw.

An appeal was prosecuted by the complainants in the Circuit' Court of Alabama, to the Supreme Court, and the citation required by the act of Congress had not been served on the appellee,, and he had no notice of the appeal. In printing the copy of the record of the Circuit Court, the return of the marshal of the district, stating that the citation to the appellee had not been served, was accidentally omitted. The Court, on motion by the counsel for the appellee, declared the decree in the case made at January term, 1840, null and void; revoked the mandate issued to the Circuit Court of Alabama, and dismissed the appeal.

AT January term, 1840, the case of Jefferson L. Edmonds et al. appellants, v. Anderson Crenshaw was brought before the Court, on appeal from the decree of the Circuit Court of Alabama, which had been given in favour of the appellee; in which Court the bill of the complainants, the appellants, was ordered to be dismissed. The Supreme Court had proceeded to hear and adjudge the case, after argument for the appellants by their counsel, Mr. Key, no counsel having appeared for Mr. Crenshaw, (14 Peters, 166,) and had reversed the decree of the Circuit Court.

It was afterwards discovered that a citation on the appeal had never been served on the appellee, and that the Court was, by an accidental circumstance, in the printing of the transcript of the record for the use of the Supreme Court, led to the belief that the appellee -had been cited to appear, in the manner required by the judiciary law. Under this belief, the Court had proceeded to. a decision of the case.

Mr. Sergeant, for Mr. Crenshaw, on notice to Mr. Key, the counsel for Jefferson L. EdmOnds and others, moved the Court, oft the first day of the term, to. set aside and annul the judgment and .decree of this Court, in the case, on the ground that no citation had been served upon the appellee, nor other notice given to him of the appeal; and that the same was heard ex parte.

• He also moved to dismiss the case on the ground that it was brought up by writ of error, instead of appeal; and whether by appeal or writ of error, it was not in time; and also on other grounds.

Opinion of the Court — Mr. Chief Justice Taney

Primary Opinion

Mr. Chief Justice Taney

delivered the opinion, of the Court.

This case was brought here by an appeal from , the decree of the Circuit Court for the Southern District of Alabama. . It was argued at the last term, on the part of the appellants $ and the decree of- the Circuit Court reversed. The argument and decision are reported in 14 Peters, 166.

Anderson Crenshaw, against whom the judgment of this Court was given, never appeared to the appeal; but the argument was heard in behalf of the appellants, and the decree of the Circuit Court reversed, under the belief that a citation had been regularly issued, and served upon him. It now appears, that an accidental circumstance led the Court into error, in this respect; and that Crenshaw was not cited to appear in the manner required by the act of Congress.

A motion has been made, at the present term, on behalf of Crenshaw, to set aside and .annul the judgment and- decree of this Court; and also .to dismiss the appeal.

As there is no case now pending here, between these parties, there is nothing upon which an order to dismiss woidd operate. But upon the facts above stated, it is very clear that the case was not legally before us at the last term; and the decree then pronounced must therefore be declared null and. void, and the mandate directed to the Circuit Court must be revoked. An order will, accordingly be issued from this Court.

On consideration of the motion made by Mr. Sergeant, on a prior day of the present term of this Court, to wit: on Monday, the 11th ultimo, and of the arguments of counsel thereupon had, as well against as in support of said motion: It is now here ordered, adjudged,'and decreed, that tfie judgment and decree of this Court, rendered in the above entitled cause, on Wednesday, the 26th day of February, A. I). 1840, be, and the same is hereby, declared utterly mill and void; and that the mandate of this Court directed to the judges of the said Circuit Court, in this cause, be, and the same is hereby revoked. And it is also now here further ordered.that-the clerk of this Codrtdo forthwith send to the judges of the Circuit Court of the United States for the Southern District of Alabama, a copy of this order of the Court, under the seal of this Court, together with a copy of the opinion of this Court, pronounced this day.

Precedents Cited (2)

Cited By Later Decisions (2)

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).