Hernandez v. Veterans' Administration
Syllabus & Case Posture
HERNANDEZ et al. v. VETERANSâ ADMINISTRATION et al.
No. 72-700.
Argued December 11, 1973
Decided March 4, 1974
Brennan, J., delivered the opinion of the Court, in which Burger, C. J., and Stewart, White, Marshall, Blackmun, Powell, and Rehnquist, JJ., joined. Douglas, J., filed a statement concurring in the result, post, p. 393.
Jack R. Petr anker, pro hac vice, and Lawrence L. Cur-tice argued the cause for petitioners. With them on the briefs were Stephen V. Bomse and Charles C. Marson.
Opinion of the Court â Mr. Justice Brennan
Primary OpinionMr. Justice Brennan
delivered the opinion of the Court.
Petitioners, like the appellee and his class in Johnson v. Robison, ante, p. 361, are Class I-O conscientious objectors who, upon completion of alternative civilian service pursuant to § 6 (j) of the Military Selective Service Act, 50 U. S. C. App. § 456 (j), and the governing regulations of the Selective Service System, 32 CFR, Part 1660, applied for educational benefits provided by the Veterans' Readjustment Benefits Act of 1966. The Veteransâ Administration denied petitionersâ application for the reasons upon which appellee Robisonâs request was denied, i. e., because a Class I-O conscientious objector who has performed alternative civilian service does not qualify under 38 U. S. C. § 1652 (a)(1) as a "veteran who . . . served on active dutyâ (defined in 38 U. S. C. § 101 (21) as âfull-time duty in the Armed Forcesâ), and is therefore not an âeligible veteranâ entitled under 38 U. S. C. § 1661 (a) to veteransâ educational benefits provided by the Veteransâ Readjustment Benefits Act of 1966.
Alleging that those sections of the 1966 Act discriminate against conscientious objectors in violation of the Fifth Amendment, and infringe the Religion Clauses of the First Amendment, petitioners filed two actions seeking declaratory, injunctive, and mandamus relief and requesting the convening of a three-judge district court. The District Court consolidated the two cases and granted the Governmentâs motion to dismiss on the grounds that âplaintiffsâ requests for affirmative relief are not within the jurisdiction of this Court due to the mandate of 38 U. S. C. § 211 (a) ... [and] the plaintiffsâ challenge . . . based on alleged violations of the Fifth and First Amendments to the United States Constitution are [sic] insubstantial and without merit.â 339 F. Supp. 913, 916 (ND Cal. 1972). Notwithstanding the District Courtâs dismissal of petitionersâ constitutional claims on the ground of insubstantiality, the Court of Appeals, as we read that courtâs opinion, construed the order of dismissal as based solely upon the jurisdictional bar of §211 (a), and affirmed the District Court on that ground. 467 F. 2d 479 (1972). We granted certiorari and set the case for oral argument with Johnson v. Robison, ante, p. 361. 411 U. S. 981 (1973).
We have held today in Johnson v. Robison that § 211 (a) does not bar judicial consideration of constitutional challenges to veteransâ benefits legislation. Accordingly, the judgment of the Court of Appeals is vacated and the case remanded for further proceedings consistent with our opinion hi Johnson v. Robison.
It is so ordered.
Mr. Justice Douglas concurs in the result for the reasons stated in his dissenting opinion in Johnson v. Robison, ante, p. 386.