Poultney v. City of Lafayette
Syllabus & Case Posture
Emily Poultney et al., Appellants, v. The City of Lafayette, Isaac T. Preston et al., Defendants.
Before a case can be dismissed under the 21st rule, regulating equity practice, there must exist, in the technical sense, a plea or demurrer on the part of the defendant, which the plaintiif shall not have replied to or set down-for hearing before the second term of the court after filing the same.
The complainant, if he chooses, may go to the hearing, on bill and answer.
This was an appeal from the Circuit Court of the United States for East Louisiana; sitting as a court of equity.
The heirs of Poultney filed a bill in chancery against the City of Lafayette and upwards of two hundred individuals.
It alleged that Poultney had purchased from, the Widow Rousseau a tract of land about, a mile and a half above the city of New Orleans in May, 1818; and that to secure the payment of part of the purchase money, he had mortgaged the same' land, to her for. $80,000, payable in five annual instalments of $16,000 each; that Poultney died in October, 1819, leaving minor children, and that 1he defendants were in possession of the property, which .the complainants claimed a right to redeem.
Opinion of the Court — Mr. Justice McLEAN
Primary OpinionMr. Justice McLEAN
delivered the opinion of the court.
This is an appeal from the decree of the Circuit Court for the eastern -district of Louisiana.
To determine the point brought up by the appeal, it is unnecessary to state the substance of the bill-or answers. On motion, the Circuit Court dismissed the bill, under the 21st nlle, because the “complainants had not set - down, if or hearing the pleas filed in this ease, nor filed replication to the answers, although more than two terms-of the-court had elapsed since filing of the same.”
The rule referred to is,- “if the.plaintiff shall not reply to, or set for hearing any plea or demurrer béfore the second term of the court after filing the same, the bill may be dismissed, with costs.” No plea had been filed in .the case, and'the demurrer filed had been overruled, so that the rule did not apply to the case as it stood at the time of the dismissal. The rule can only apply to demurrers and pleas technically so called. And there is no other rule of proceeding which authorized the décree of the court. The complainant may, if he choose, go to the hearing on the bill and answer.
The decree of the Circuit Court is reversed, and the cause is remanded for further proceedings.