SCOTUS-Cases.net

Spalding v. People ex rel. Backus

45 U.S. 21 1846-01 7,464 Words
Full Case Caption
Lyman A. Spalding, Plaintiff in error, v. The People of the State of New York, ex rel. Frederic F. Backus, Defendants
Official & Parallel Citations
4 How. 21 · 45 U.S. 21 · 11 L. Ed. 858
Court & Volume
Supreme Court of the United States · 45 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

Lyman A. Spalding, Plaintiff in error, v. The People of the State of New York, ex rel. Frederic F. Backus, Defendants.

This case whs brought up from the. Supreme Court for the Trial of Impeachments and the C orrection of Errors of the S tatic of New York, by a writ of efror issued under the ?6th. section of ;the Judiciary Act. .

The facts were these.

The. relator, Frederick F; Bapkus, previous -tojthe.20th .day of July, 1840, had obtained' á júdgment.in the Supreme.Cpiirt of . the11 State of New York against Lyman A.. Spalding,.the, plaintiff in error, -for the-nonperformance of promises,, and. on the . said last mentioned day die relator, as complainant, filed a . creditor’s bill against the said Spalding, in the Court of Chancery of said State, before the Yice-ChanoeUór of the Eighth Circuit, on which an injunction was issued and served on said Spalding, to restrain, him, among other things, from collecting, receiving, .transferring, selling, assigning, delivering, or in any way or manner using, controlling, interfering or meddling with, or disposing of, any property, móney, or things in action belonging to him.

On the 13th- day of December, .1841, an order was made by said court to attach said Spalding for a violation of said- injunction, and such proceedings-were had in said court, that on the 21st day of March, 1842, the said court declared and-adjudged that the said Lyman A. Spaldihg had. been and was guilty of a contempt of court in wilfully violating said injunction, by disposing of property and paying out money contrary to the terms of said injunction; and that such misconduct of the said Lyman A.. Spalding was calculated to and did impair, impede, and prejudice the rights and remedies of the complainant in the said cause, and jt was ordered that he pay a fine for said contempt to the amount of $ 3,000, and the costs and expenses in relation to said contempt of ‡ 196-51; and that he be committed to the common jail of the county of Niagara, until the fine,, costs, and- expensed are paid, and that a mittimus issue accordingly to the sheriff. And it was also ordered, that the costs and expenses be paid to the solicitor of the relator, and the $ 3,000 be paid to the clerk of said court, subject to the further order of the court.

On the 6th day of May, 1842, an alias mittimus was issued; on the 7th day of May, the said Spalding was arrested, and continued under said arrest until the 29th day of September, 1842.

Opinion of the Court — Mr. Chief-Justice TANEY

Primary Opinion

Mr. Chief-Justice TANEY

delivered the opinion of the court.

The court have considered this case, and have come to the conclusion that the judgment of the Court of the State of New York for the Correction of Errors must be affirmed. But there is. some difference among the justices who concur in affirming the judgment as to the principles, upon which the affirmance ought to be placed. No further opinion will, therefore, be delivered, than merely to pronounce the judgment of this court, affirming.'the judgment rendered by the state court.

Dissenting Opinion — Mr. Justice McLEAN. .

Mr. Justice McLEAN. .

I dissent from the judgment of the court.,

Mr. Justice WAYNE..

I do not concur with the majority of the court, and think that the judgment of the Court for the Trial of Impeachments and for die Correction of Errors should be reversed.

Cited By Later Decisions (2)

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).