Neilson v. Lagow
Syllabus & Case Posture
Hall Neilson, Plaintiff in error, v. Wilson Lagow.
Where, upon the trial of a casé in a State court, a party claims the land in dispute,. •' under an authority which he alleges has been exercised by the Secretary of the Treasury, in behalf of the United States, and the decision was against the validity of the authority, the party is entitled to have his case brought to this court under the twenty-fifth section of the Judiciary Act.
This case was brought up from the Supreme Court of Indiana, by a writ of error isued .under the twenty-fifth section of the Judiciary Act.
. As a motion was madeto dismiss it for want.of jurisdiction, and , the merits , of the case were hot discussed; a brief statement of the facts will'be sufficient.
. It was an action of disseizin, similar to. ah ejectment, brought by Lagow in the Circuit Court for the county of Knox ahd State of Indiana, against Neilson, Billis, and Thomas, to recover possession of a piece of property known by the name of the Steam-mill Tract, lying in the town of Vincennes. Billis and Thomas disclaimed all interest, and the. suit Was carried on by Neilson alone. On the 19th of September, 1821, Lagow and others conveyed the'property to the President, Directors, and Company of the Bank of Vincennes, their successors and assigns, for ever, for the consideration of $ 98,000.
On the 1st of July, 1822, the bank conveyed this, property to Badoliet, Harrison; and Buntin, and their successors, in trust for the use of the Secretary of the Treasury of the United States, in extinguishment of the debt due by the bank to the United States. The trustees were to sell,whenever- requested by the Secretary of the Treasury, and continue, to pay until the United States were paid the sum of $120,308, with interest. The Secretary of the Treasury was vested with power to fill up vacancies in the trust.
Opinion of the Court — Mr. Chief Justice TANEY
Primary OpinionMr. Chief Justice TANEY
delivered the opinion of the court.
It appears, that, at the trial in the State court, the plaintiff in error claimed the land in dispute under au authority which he alleged had been exercised by the 'Secretary of the Treasury in behalf of the United States; and the decision was against the validity of the authority thus alleged to have been exercised. Whether the title, of the plaintiff in error can be maintained under it, or not, will be the subject of inquiry when the case is heard on its merits. That question is not now before the court, and the only point tó be determined at this time is, whether we have jurisdiction to try and decide it. We think it is:evidently one of the cases prescribed for in the twenty-fifth section of the act of 1789 ; and the motion to dismiss is therefore overruled.
Order. .
On.consideration of the motion made in this cause on ¿ prior day of the present term, to wit, on Friday, the 2d instant, to dismiss the writ of error, and of the arguménts of counsel-thereupon had, as well against as in support of the motion, it is now here ordered by the court, that the said motion be, and . the same is hereby, overruled.