SCOTUS-Cases.net

Stuart v. Laird

5 U.S. 299 1803-03-02 3,970 Words
Full Case Caption
STUART v. LAIRD
Official & Parallel Citations
1 Cranch 299 Β· 5 U.S. 299 Β· 2 L. Ed. 115
Court & Volume
Supreme Court of the United States Β· 5 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

STUART v. LAIRD.

Error from the 5th circuit in the Virginia district.

A cause may, by act of congress, be transferred from inferior tribunal to another.

A contemporary and exposition of the constitution, practised and acquiesced under for a period of years, fixes the construction; and the court will not shake or control it.

An action of covenant was brought in January 1801, in β€˜ the court of the United States for the middle circuit in the β€œ Virginia district,” by John Laird, a citizen of the state of Maryland, for and on behalf of Laird and Robertson of port Glasgow and subjects of the king of Great Britain, against Hugh Stuart, a citizen and inhabitant of the state of Virginia.

At the rules in February, 1801, there was an office judgment against the defendant for damages, &c. β€œ which β€œ damages,” says the record, β€œ are to be enquired of and " assessed by a jury to be summoned by the marshal, and β€œ impannelled before the next court of the United States β€œ for the middle circuit in the Virginia district, which com- β€œ mences on the 22d day of May next ensuing, and so the β€œ cause aforesaid stood continued, by virtue of the statute β€œ in such case made and provided, until the court of the Uni- β€œ ted States for the fourth circuit in the Virginia district, con- β€œ tinued by adjournment and holden at the capitol in the β€œ city of Richmond aforesaid, on Thursday the 17th day β€œ of December 1801; at which day, to wit, at a court of β€œ the United States for the fourth circuit in the eastern β€œ district of Virginia, continued by adjournment, and β€œ holden at the capitol in the city aforesaid, before the β€œ honorable the judges of the said court, came as well β€œ the plaintiff,” &c. and the office judgment being set aside and issue joined upon the plea of covenants performed, there was verdict and judgment for the plaintiffs; upon which, a fieri facias issued reciting, in the usual form, the judgment recovered β€œ in the court of the United States for β€œ the fourth circuit in the eastern Virginia district,” and returnable β€œ before the judges of the said court at Rich- β€œ mond, in the eastern Virginia district, on the 26th day β€œ of April next.” β€œ Witness Philip Barton Key, esq. chief β€œ judge of the said court.”

Opinion of the Court β€” Paterson, justice,

Primary Opinion

The chief justice, having tried the cause in the court below, declined giving an opinion.

Paterson, justice,

(judge Cushing being absent on account of ill health,) delivered the opinion of the court.

On an action instituted by John Laird against Hugh Stuart, a judgment was entered in a court for the fourth circuit in the eastern district of Virginia, in December term 1801. On this judgment, an execution was issued, returnable to April term 1802, in the same court. In the term of December 1802, John Laird obtained judgment at a court for the fifth circuit in the Virginia district, against Hugh Stuart and Charles L. Carter, upon their bond for the forthcoming and delivery of certain property therein mentioned, which had been levied upon by virtue of the above execution against the said Hugh Stuart.

Two reasons have been assigned by counsel for reversing the judgment on the forthcoming bond. 1. That as the bond was given for the delivery of property levied on by virtue of an execution issuing out of, and returnable to a court for the fourth circuit, no other court could legally proceed upon the said bond. This is true, if there be no statutable provision to direct and authorize such proceeding. Congress have constitutional authority to establish from time to time such inferior tribunals as they may think proper; and to transfer a cause from one such tribunal to another. In this last particular, there are no words in the constitution to prohibit or restrain the exercise of legislative power.

The present is a case of this kind. It is nothing more than the removal of the suit brought by Stuart against Laird from the court of the fourth circuit to the court of the fifth circuit, which is authorized to proceed upon and carry it into full effect. This is apparent from the ninth section of the act entitled, β€œ an act to amend the judicial β€œ system of the United States,” passed the 29th of April, 1802. The forthcoming bond is an appendage to the cause, or rather a component part of the proceedings.

2d. Another reason for reversal is, that the judges of the supreme court have no right to sit as circuit judges, not being appointed as such, or in other words, that they ought to have distinct commissions for that purpose. To this objection, which is of recent date, it is sufficient to observe, that practice and acquiescence under it for a period of several years, commencing with the organization of the judicial system, affords an irresistable answer, and has indeed fixed the construction. It is a contemporary interpretation of the most forcible nature. This practical exposition is too strong and obstinate to be shaken or controlled. Of course, the question is at rest, and ought not now to be disturbed.

Judgment affirmed.

Cited By Later Decisions (29)

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. Β§ 105) Β· Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).