SCOTUS-Cases.net

Wilson v. Lenox

5 U.S. 194 1803-02-26 6,515 Words
Full Case Caption
WILSON v. LENOX AND MAITLAND
Official & Parallel Citations
1 Cranch 194 · 5 U.S. 194 · 2 L. Ed. 79
Court & Volume
Supreme Court of the United States · 5 U.S.

Syllabus & Case Posture

WILSON v. LENOX AND MAITLAND.

A declaration in debt, under the law of Virginia, upon a protested bill of exchange for the principal, interest, damages and cost of protest, must aver the amount of those costs of protest. Quere, whether if the holder of a bill of exchange, after due notice to the indorser of the non-payment by the drawee, charge the bill in account current against the drawer, and upon the whole of that account the balance due is less than the amount of the bill, the indorser is thereby discharged? Whether the indorser is discharged by the holder's receipt of part from the drawer, after due notice given to the indorser? Whether it be necessary to aver a protest for non-acceptance in an action on protest for nonpayment? Whether the drawer be a competent witness for the indorser in an action against the latter?

Error to the circuit court of the district of Columbia sitting at Alexandria, on a judgment obtained by the present defendants in error, against the plaintiff in error, in an action of debt, as indorser of a bill of exchange for L.300 sterling, drawn on the 2d January, 1799, at Alexandria, by A. and W. Ramsay, on Findley, Bannatyne and co. London, at ninety days fight, payable to Wilson, the plaintiff in error, and by him indorsed to the defendants. This bill was presented for acceptance on the 28th of February, 1799, and refused, and on the 1st of June, 1799, protested for non-payment. The declaration was "of a plea that he render unto them "the sum of L.300 sterling, with damages, interest and "charges of protest, on a protested bill of exchange, which

"to them he owes, and from them unjustly detains," and goes on to state the drawing of the bill of exchange "ac- " cording to the custom of merchants," the indorsement by Wilson to Lenox and Maitland; the refusal of Findley, Bannatyne and co. to accept the bill on its being presented for acceptance (but does not state a protest for nonacceptance, nor notice of the non-acceptance given to Wilson) and the protest, "in due form, according to the custom "of merchants," for non-payment; "of which the said " defendant afterwards, to wit, on the day of " in the year aforesaid, at the town and county "aforesaid, had notice, whereby, and by force of the "act of assembly of the commonwealth of Virginia, in " such case made and provided, action accrued to the "said plaintiffs, to demand and have of the said defend- "ant the said sum of £.300 sterling, with damages, in- "terest and charges of protest; nevertheless, the said de- "fendant, although thereto often required, hath not paid "unto the said plaintiffs the said sum of three hundred "pounds sterling, with damages, interest and charges of "protest, but the same to pay hath hitherto refused, and "still doth refuse, to the damage of the plaintiffs, 750 "dollars, and thereupon they bring suit, &c" The

The act of assembly of Virginia, which gives the action of debt on a protested bill of exchange (revised code, p. 121) provides, "that where any bill of exchange is or "shall be drawn for the payment of any sum of money, " in which the value is or shall be expressed to be re- "ceived, and such bill is or shall be protested for non-ac- "ceptance or non-payment, the drawer, or indorser, "shall be subject to the payment of fifteen per centum "damages thereon, and the bill shall carry an interest of "five per centum per annum, from the date of the pro- "test, until the money, therein drawn for, shall be fully "satisfied and paid."

"§ 3. It shall be lawful for any person or persons, having a right to demand any sum of money upon a "protested bill of exchange, to commence and prose " cute an action of debt, for principal, damages, interest "and charges of protest, against the drawers or indorsers "jointly, or against either of them separately; and judg- "ment shall and may be given for such principal, da- "mages and charges, and interest upon such principal, "after the rate aforesaid, to the time of such judgment, "and for the interest upon the said principal money re"covered, after the rate of five per centum per annum, "until the same shall be fully satisfied."

Opinion of the Court — The Chief Justice

Primary Opinion

The Chief Justice

delivered the opinion of the court.

In this case there was an objection taken to the plaintiffs’ declaration, which was in debt on a protested bill of exchange. The declaration claims £ 300 sterling, with damages, interest and charges of protest, on a protested bill of exchange, without stating, in any part of it, the amount of those charges. The verdict is for the debt in the declaration mentioned, on which judgment is rendered, to be discharged by a less sum.

The objection is, that the demand is uncertain, in as much as the amount of the charges of protest, which constitute a part of the debt claimed, is not stated.

The clause of the act on which this suit is instituted is in these words, “ It shall be lawful for any person or “ persons,” &c “to prosecute an action of debt, for prin- “ cipal, damages, interest, and charges of protest against the “ drawers,” &c. The charges of protest constitute an essential part of the debt, and the declaration would not pursue the act, if those charges should be omitted. This part therefore cannot be considered as surplussage. It is a component part of the debt for which the action is given. Being a necessary part, its amount ought to be stated with as much certainty as the amount of the bill.

As this is a mere technical objection, the court would disregard it, if it was not a principle, deemed essential in the action of debt, that the declaration should state the demand with certainty.

The cases cited by the counsel for the defendant in error, do not come up to this case. They relate to different debts; this to a single debt composed of different parts.

Judgment reversed and arrested.

See the case of Rudder v. Price, 1 H. Bl. reports, 550.

Precedents Cited (2)

Public Domain Federal Judicial Work (17 U.S.C. § 105) · Harvard Law School Caselaw Access Project (CAP).