Cervantes v. United States
Syllabus & Case Posture
Cruz Cervantes, Appellant, v. The United States.
Upon an appeal from the District Court of the United States for the Northern District of California, where it did not appear, from the proceedings, whether the land, claimed was within the Northern or Southern District, this court will roverse the judgment of the District Court and remand the case for the purp9.se of making its jurisdiction apparent, (if it should have any,) and of correcting any other matter of form or substance which may be necessary.
This was an appeal from the District Court of the United States for Northern California.
In February, 1852, Cervantes filed before the board of commissioners to ascertain and settle the private land claims in' California, the following claim:
Cruz Cervantes, a. citizen of said State, gives notice that he claims, by virtue of a grant from the Mexican nation, a tract of land situated i.n the county of Santa Clara, in said State, and known by the name of San Joaquin or Rosa Morada, with tb° boundaries described in the grant thereof, to wit: on one side the arroyo of San Felipe; on- the second side, the hills or mountains of San Joaquin; on the third, the arroyo of Santa Anna; and on the fourth, a line drawn through the plain of San Juan.
Said land was conceded to claimant by a grant issued on the 1st day of April, 1836, by Don Nicolas Gutienez, superior political chief ad interim of California, and thereby authorized to grant lands in the name and on behalf of the Mexican nation. On the 18th February, 1841, judicial possession was given to claimant by Juan Miguel Anzar, Judge of First Instance of that jurisdiction.
Opinion of the Court — Mr. Justice McLEAN
Primary OpinionMr. Justice McLEAN
delivered the following opinion of the court.
It does not appear, from the proceedings before the District Court, that the land claimed is within the Northern Judicial District of California. This .is necessary to give that court jurisdiction. It can exercise no power over any claim, where the land lies in the Southern Judicial District of the same State. ,
This coúrt has often held, unless the jurisdiction of the Circuit or District Court appear in the record, the judgment of such court may be reversed on a writ of error. It is therefore important, that in dealing with land titles, the jurisdiction of the inferior court should appear in the proceeding.
From a map of the State of California, recently published, it appears the land claimed in this case lies in the Southern District, and if so, no jurisdiction attached to the court where the proceeding was Instituted.
■ For the»purpose of correcting the proceeding in this respect, the decision of the District Court is reversed, and the cause is remanded to that court with leave to amend the proceeding in regard to the jurisdiction of the District Court, and to any other matter of form or substance which may be necessary.
Order.
This cause came to b^ heard on the transcript of the record from the District Court of the United States • for the Northern District of California, and it not appearing therefrom that the land claimed is within the Northern Judicial District of California, it is, on consideration thereof now here ordered and decreed by this court that the decree of the said District Court in this cause be, and the same is hereby reversed, and that this cause be, and the same is hereby remanded to the said District Court, with leave to amend the proceedings in regard to the jurisdiction of the said District Court, and also in regard to any other matter of form or substance which may be necessary.